Right-to-die: Bid to overturn UK's assisted suicide ban is rejected

Right-to-die campaigners Paul Lamb and Jane Nicklinson have had their bid rejected by the European Court.

The European Court has rejected a bid to overturn the UK ban on assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia.

Paul Lamb, a paralysed former builder and Jane Nicklinson, widow of the late Tony Nicklinson, who suffered from locked-in syndrome until his death three years ago, went to Europe in an attempt to change UK law on assisted dying.

They were attempting to use the European Convention on Human Rights to argue that a ban on assisted suicide in the 1961 Suicide Act should be overturned.

The court said in its written judgment: "In its decision in the case of Nicklinson and Lamb v the United Kingdom the European Court of Human Rights has unanimously declared the applications inadmissible. The decision is final."

Mr Nicklinson's daughter Lauren tweeted: "Assisted suicide is an issue that'll become more pressing everyday. It didn't die with dad & it won't be forgotten now our campaign is over."

Referring to those who travel to Switzerland to die by choice, she added: "Assisted dying must be addressed, the longer we export it to Switzerland the longer we prolong the cruel suffering of so many #righttodie."

article,article,article,article Related

The judgment does however leave open the possibility that a UK court might decide in future to legalise assisted dying.

The British Humanist Association, which campaigns in favour of assisted dying for the terminally ill and incurably suffering, intervened in support of the Nicklinsons and Lamb. Andrew Copson, the chief executive, said: "We are disappointed by today's decision which simply passes the buck back to the UK courts and Parliament but in the meantime it cruelly leaves those who are terminally ill or incurably suffering and have a settled wish to end their lives in a dignified manner unable to seek assistance to do so and instead forced to continue their lives in pain.

"We will continue to press this matter through the courts and in Parliament until one body or another recognises the rights of individuals like Tony and Paul to have their wishes fulfilled."

The UK Supreme Court dismissed the cases last summer but indicated the matter could be revisited if Parliament failed to do so. Lord Falconer's bill on the issue was not given enough time to progress and although a new Assisted Dying Bill is being proposed, it is also unlikely to get the time that would be needed to become law.

The European Court of Human Rights decided that in Jane Nicklinson's case the Supreme Court was entitled to make the decision that it did. In Paul Lamb's case, the court said the arguments put forward had not been fully considered by the domestic courts. Both decisions therefore leave the door open for further court challenges, the British Humanist Association said.

Dr Peter Saunders of the Christian Medical Fellowship said: "It is written, we shall not kill. Human beings are made in the image of God. They are incredibly precious. There is a general prohibition in Scripture against the taking of innocent human life. Jesus upheld the spirit of the law and as we know went beyond it in the spirit of love and self-sacrifice. This has provided not only the basis of the prohibition on killing the innocent, but the basis for the compassionate care and the hospice movement. We are called as God's people to make sacrifices and bear one another's burdens. One expression of that is how we spend our time and money finding alternatives to assisted suicide and euthanasia such as compassionate care."

related articles
What you need to know about the Assisted Dying Bill
What you need to know about the Assisted Dying Bill

What you need to know about the Assisted Dying Bill

\'Euthanasia has become fashionable\': Ethics expert on the right to die
'Euthanasia has become fashionable': Ethics expert on the right to die

'Euthanasia has become fashionable': Ethics expert on the right to die

Brittany Maynard: How Christians should think through issues of assisted dying
Brittany Maynard: How Christians should think through issues of assisted dying

Brittany Maynard: How Christians should think through issues of assisted dying

Leading bioethicist condemns Assisted Dying Bill
Leading bioethicist condemns Assisted Dying Bill

Leading bioethicist condemns Assisted Dying Bill

News
Some reflections on Purim and the meaningfulness of Jewish-Christian dialogue
Some reflections on Purim and the meaningfulness of Jewish-Christian dialogue

Hebrew scholar and Jewish academic Irene Lancaster reflects on Purim and Jewish-Christian dialogue.

Gluttony and the Holy Spirit’s fruit of self-control
Gluttony and the Holy Spirit’s fruit of self-control

This excessive indulgence goes against the Christian spirit of self-control and can lead to adverse spiritual and physical consequences.

Christian activist's arrest for anti-monarchy slogan was unlawful
Christian activist's arrest for anti-monarchy slogan was unlawful

A left-wing Christian activist who shouted “who elected him?” at a proclamation ceremony for King Charles III was arrested unlawfully.

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe talks about Iranian imprisonment ordeal and her faith
Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe talks about Iranian imprisonment ordeal and her faith

Nazanin Zaghari-Ratcliffe has spoken about her six years of imprisonment in Iran and her complex relationship with faith during and after her ordeal.