'A terrible idea': Amnesty draws intense fire for its move to decriminalise sex trade

Romanian prostitutes pose in the brothel Pussy Club in Schoenefeld, Germany, on April 15, 2009. Reuters

Following the lead taken by some Christian groups, anti-human trafficking advocates, medical practitioners and famous celebrities have spoken in one voice against the decision taken by non-government organisation Amnesty International to approve a new policy seeking to decriminalise the global sex trade.

Tina Frundt, founder of Courtney's House in Washington, D.C. which helps children victimised by human traffickers, called Amnesty's decision "a terrible idea."

She pointed out that decriminalising the sex trade already did not work in some countries. In Germany, for instance, brothels were able to obtain fake identification for women from other countries whom they force into the sex trade.

"This has been tried and failed – in the Netherlands, in Germany – they've closed down over 30 brothels because we are talking about a criminal industry that we are trying to legalise," Frundt, herself a survivor of child sex trafficking, explained.

"Criminals think like criminals. It's a die-hard criminal business making millions," she added.

Therapist Candace Wheeler from Restoration Ministries, an organisation which helps trafficking survivors in the process of healing, said Amnesty's decision has very serious implications.

"What they have found (in Amsterdam) is that tolerance is not protecting women who are in prostitution there, because it's mostly women who are trafficked from other countries, and they are realising that their tolerance is a huge problem," Wheeler said.

"If it's decriminalised, then that just opens up the door for that kind of business. We could have established brothels and red light districts, and then crime comes with that, and drugs – and I am the person that gets to see them afterwards and try and heal them," she added.

Award-winning Hollywood celebrities such as Anne Hathaway, Meryl Streep and Kate Winslet, meanwhile, signed a letter to Amnesty appealing that the non-government organisation reconsider its decision, pointing out the "inescapable harms the sex trade inflicted."

related articles
Amnesty International\'s bid to legalise  prostitution draws flak from celebrities
Amnesty International's bid to legalise prostitution draws flak from celebrities

Amnesty International's bid to legalise prostitution draws flak from celebrities

Prostitution as a human right: Why Amnesty International is on the verge of a terrible mistake
Prostitution as a human right: Why Amnesty International is on the verge of a terrible mistake

Prostitution as a human right: Why Amnesty International is on the verge of a terrible mistake

Obama criticised over \'watered down\' human trafficking report
Obama criticised over 'watered down' human trafficking report

Obama criticised over 'watered down' human trafficking report

Campaigners slam Amnesty call for prostitution to be decriminalised
Campaigners slam Amnesty call for prostitution to be decriminalised

Campaigners slam Amnesty call for prostitution to be decriminalised

News
Christians 'deeply sad' as Scottish Parliament backs assisted suicide bill
Christians 'deeply sad' as Scottish Parliament backs assisted suicide bill

Liam McArthur's bill has passed an initial vote in the Scottish Parliament despite opposition.

Dozens of Scottish church leaders warn against legalising assisted suicide
Dozens of Scottish church leaders warn against legalising assisted suicide

Pastors and Christian leaders across Scotland have signed an open letter to MSPs urging them to vote against a draft bill that seeks to legalise assisted suicide. 

Sequel to hit Christian movie 'I Can Only Imagine' gets new release date
Sequel to hit Christian movie 'I Can Only Imagine' gets new release date

The release date for the faith-based film “I Can Only Imagine 2,” the sequel to the 2018 box office hit, is moving from March 20, 2026, to Feb. 20, 2026, Lionsgate and Kingdom Story Company have announced.

First Minister John Swinney among MSPs to vote against Scottish assisted dying bill
First Minister John Swinney among MSPs to vote against Scottish assisted dying bill

Scotland’s First Minister, John Swinney, has confirmed he will vote against the controversial Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill, ahead of its pivotal Stage 1 vote set for Tuesday evening.