Alaska Supreme Court strikes down abortion parental notification law for minors

Anti-abortion supporters march on Capitol Hill during the National March for Life rally in Washington on Jan. 22, 2016. Reuters

Minors can now get abortion in Alaska without informing their parents.

This came about after the Alaska Supreme Court stuck down on July 22 the voter-enacted Parental Notification Law, which requires a 48-hour advance parental notice before a physician can perform abortion on a minor.

"We conclude that the Notification Law violates the Alaska Constitution's equal protection guarantee and cannot be enforced," the state Supreme Court ruled. "And as a court we are not concerned with whether abortion is right, wrong, moral, or immoral, or with whether abortions should be available to minors without restriction. We are concerned only with whether, given its stated underlying justifications, the current Notification Law complies with the Alaska Constitution's equal protection guarantee — and it does not."

Planned Parenthood of the Great Northwest challenged the law in court. The notification law was approved by voters in 2010.

"Parents are the individuals who care most for the physical and emotional well-being of their children. The primary vested interest that an abortion clinic has is its bottom line. We had hoped the Alaska Supreme Court would keep its promise to the people of Alaska to permit a parental notice law designed to protect parental rights and the safety of children," said Kevin Clarkson,  a lawyer affiliated with the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) who defended the law in court last year.

In a previous case, the Supreme Court ruled that "the Alaska Constitution permits a statutory scheme which ensures that parents are notified so that they can be engaged in their daughters' important decisions in these matters."

In his dissenting opinion, Chief Justice Craig Stowers wrote, "Moreover the majority and concurrence ignore in practical effect the interests and rights of the State and parents in taking steps to assist a minor who is seeking an abortion in receiving information and counseling concerning all aspects of that decision."

He said the U.S. Supreme Court stated "that the State has a legitimate right to enact laws designed to encourage a woman contemplating abortion to be informed regarding the effects that abortion may have on her and regarding alternatives to abortion."

Stowers said by invalidating the parents' right to discuss with their daughter the effects and alternatives to abortion, "the Alaska Court today trivializes and makes this right of no effect."

A court upheld most provisions of the law in October 2012, concluding that it is reasonable because "minors may be pleasantly surprised when underestimated parents support, comfort and affirm them. Or a teen might overlook available resources. Her parents might help raise the child, and so make college or military service feasible. Parental notification undoubtedly can open doors to unconsidered options for an otherwise isolated young woman," according to the ADF.

related articles
Phil Robertson suggests Donald Trump undergo a high-profile conversion to evangelical Christianity
Phil Robertson suggests Donald Trump undergo a high-profile conversion to evangelical Christianity

Phil Robertson suggests Donald Trump undergo a high-profile conversion to evangelical Christianity

Billy Graham cites worst sin people can commit
Billy Graham cites worst sin people can commit

Billy Graham cites worst sin people can commit

Planned Parenthood to close 6 clinics — a move driven by abortion and profit, pro-life advocates say
Planned Parenthood to close 6 clinics — a move driven by abortion and profit, pro-life advocates say

Planned Parenthood to close 6 clinics — a move driven by abortion and profit, pro-life advocates say

Sorry Republicans, but you do not have a monopoly on Christian faith
Sorry Republicans, but you do not have a monopoly on Christian faith

Sorry Republicans, but you do not have a monopoly on Christian faith

Doctors who object to abortion face \'harassment and abuse\', say MPs
Doctors who object to abortion face 'harassment and abuse', say MPs

Doctors who object to abortion face 'harassment and abuse', say MPs

Mike Pence: the evangelical former Catholic who may yet save Donald Trump
Mike Pence: the evangelical former Catholic who may yet save Donald Trump

Mike Pence: the evangelical former Catholic who may yet save Donald Trump

US cardinal says Islam \'wants to govern the world\'
US cardinal says Islam 'wants to govern the world'

US cardinal says Islam 'wants to govern the world'

Clinton picks Catholic former missionary Tim Kaine as running mate
Clinton picks Catholic former missionary Tim Kaine as running mate

Clinton picks Catholic former missionary Tim Kaine as running mate

Vice-President Kaine? Find out six facts about his faith
Vice-President Kaine? Find out six facts about his faith

Vice-President Kaine? Find out six facts about his faith

Cardinal Burke: \'My mother was advised to abort me\'
Cardinal Burke: 'My mother was advised to abort me'

Cardinal Burke: 'My mother was advised to abort me'

News
When New Year’s Day used to be on 25 March
When New Year’s Day used to be on 25 March

When New Year’s Day used to be on 25 March25 March is known as Lady Day, also known as the Annunciation of the Lord, and it used to be the old New Year’s Day.  This is the story …

Astronaut says faith in Jesus sustained him through 9 months stranded in space
Astronaut says faith in Jesus sustained him through 9 months stranded in space

NASA astronaut Butch Wilmore, who was trapped aboard the International Space Station for 9 months with fellow astronaut, Suni Williams, is attributing his endurance during the mission to one thing above all - his faith in Jesus Christ.

UK faith leaders urge government to be ‘bold and ambitious’ in Child Poverty Strategy
UK faith leaders urge government to be ‘bold and ambitious’ in Child Poverty Strategy

In a show of unity, 35 senior faith leaders from across the UK have appealed to the government to take a “bold, and ambitious” approach in its upcoming Child Poverty Strategy. 

Hopes remain for Royal visit to Vatican
Hopes remain for Royal visit to Vatican

Buckingham Palace sources have revealed that King Charles III and Queen Camilla remain hopeful that their planned visit to the Vatican for a meeting with Pope Francis will take place on their upcoming trip to the nation-state, despite the pontiff’s recent illness.