Are ISIS atrocities 'genocide'? Why the word matters

Next week the House of Commons will debate whether to recognise ISIS atrocities against Christians, Yazidis and other minorities as 'genocide'.

The European Parliament and the US administration have already taken this step. But little has changed. Reports continue to emerge of crucifixions, beheadings, rapes and slavery against a number of religious minorities, and many Muslims.

The debate on whether ISIS has committed genocide will happen next Wednesday afternoon. Reuters

So what is the significance of using the term genocide? Why does David Cameron appear to be so unwilling to join his allies in the White House?

Lord Alton of Liverpool, the Catholic peer who has led the parliament campaign to adopt the word genocide, told Christian Today the reluctance surrounds the legal implications that follow such a declaration.

"This is not just about words. There are legal obligations," he said.

As a signatory to the 'convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide (CPPCG)', Britain is required to prevent and punish genocide whenever it is declared.

"This is why states are hesitant and reticent to name genocide," Lord Alton said.

"If you look back at Rwanda [genocide in 1994], the world did not get around to naming it as genocide until over one million people had died.

"We have already repeated our mistakes with this crisis but must not delay further. This is why the European Parliament and US House of Representatives have all unanimously named it genocide."

The peer told Christian Today he expected a "change in approach" from Britain if it were to make such a declaration. He said this should come "not least in how we treat those victims of genocide who have fled to our country for asylum".

Until now the government's response has been that this is a matter for the "international judicial system rather than legislatures, governments or other non-judicial bodies". In essence they seem to be saying it is not a matter for politicians.

On the face of it this does not seem unreasonable.

However once you examine the mechanics of how these matters work it is absurd.

The International Criminal Court (ICC) who would prosecute war criminals and perpetrators of genocide, cannot act in Syria or Iraq unless it receives instructions from the UN Security Council. Indeed a year ago the ICC said it "stands ready" to investigate but needs a referral from the council.

The UK is one of five permanent members of the UN Security Council. As such it is in a position to exert significant influence for an investigation.

Alton continued: "It is vitally important to pursuade the government to honour our commitment as signatories of the convention.

"No one who has heard of the atrocities committed could deny genocide has taken place.

"Words matter. And so do deeds."

related articles
Coptic bishop welcomes US announcement that ISIS committed genocide

Coptic bishop welcomes US announcement that ISIS committed genocide

Cameron under pressure from Christian peers to label ISIS atrocities 'genocide'

Cameron under pressure from Christian peers to label ISIS atrocities 'genocide'

Government moves towards declaring ISIS atrocities in Middle East 'genocide'

Government moves towards declaring ISIS atrocities in Middle East 'genocide'

Parliament to debate ISIS 'genocide'

Parliament to debate ISIS 'genocide'

News
Telling the untold story behind elections
Telling the untold story behind elections

There’s an untold story about the elections we have just had across England - and maybe about every election that ever gets held anywhere. It’s a story that matters just as much as the election results. 

Madagascan Christians called to lead by example in struggling country
Madagascan Christians called to lead by example in struggling country

“We cannot serve Jesus Christ in church, and the devil outside.”

Churches and cathedrals help kick off VE Day 80th anniversary commemorations
Churches and cathedrals help kick off VE Day 80th anniversary commemorations

Churches and cathedrals are playing a big part in this week's 80th anniversary commemorations of Victory in Europe - or VE - Day which marked the end of World War II in Europe in 1945. 

Faith, justice and change: Niall Cooper reflects on nearly three decades with Church Action on Poverty
Faith, justice and change: Niall Cooper reflects on nearly three decades with Church Action on Poverty

After 28 years at the helm of Church Action on Poverty, Niall Cooper is stepping down from his role as director – marking the end of a remarkable chapter in Christian social justice and offering a moment for both reflection and gratitude.