Assisted suicide proponent withdraws bill before Minnesota Senate committee's vote

Gregory Dugan of Washington D.C. leads a group of protesters against doctor-assisted suicide in front of the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington D.C. on Jan. 8, 2015. Reuters

A bill that seeks to legalise assisted suicide in Minnesota was withdrawn by its author before a committee voted for it on Wednesday.

S.F. 1880, or the Minnesota Compassionate Care Act, appeared to be dead after lead author Senator Chris Eaton withdrew the bill, which would likely have been killed if the committee voted on it.

Under the bill, a terminally ill person may request for aid in dying where a physician will prescribe medication, which the patient will self-administer.

A public hearing on the bill drew physicians, nurses, attorneys, and people with disability who warned of the dangers of the bill to the vulnerable section of society, according to National Right to Life.

More than 100 people who are against the measure attended the hearing, wearing "No assisted suicide" stickers.

The Minnesotans Against Assisted Suicide (MNAAS) submitted written testimony to the Minnesota Senate Health, Human Services and Housing committee.

"We have an obligation to the terminally ill and their loved ones. But this bill will not help that cause," said Dr. Thomas Nobrega, a St. Paul cardiologist. "This bill is about giving a patient the means to die by a drug overdose. It creates an irreconcilable conflict between the doctor as a compassionate guide and healer, and the motivation to expedite death."

Dr. James Joyce said he has seen the "ravages" of suicide and added that legal assisted suicide would severely destroy the doctor-patient relationship,

"If they can't trust us, we can't help them," he said.

Nurse Kathy Ware is a mother of a disabled son, Kylen, and spoke about the need to protect persons with disabilities.

"People wouldn't pursue assisted suicide if they had the help and care they needed for their loved one. We in the disability community are not asking for pity. We want help and we want to be treated with value," she said.

Elizabeth Bakewicz, who has terminal cancer and brain disease, asked the committee not to pass the bill.

"Under this bill I am treated as nothing but a list of burdens. But I am a human being," she said.

Neil Helgeson, board president of The Arc Minnesota, a disability rights organisation, has a son with disability. He said those who deal with disabilities generally enjoy life.

"This places their lives at extraordinary risk. "Senate File 1880 poses a grave threat to individuals with disabilities," he said.

related articles
Sunday Trading: The stability of families must not be sacrificed on the altar of profit
Sunday Trading: The stability of families must not be sacrificed on the altar of profit

Sunday Trading: The stability of families must not be sacrificed on the altar of profit

California governor signs bill legalising physician-assisted suicide
California governor signs bill legalising physician-assisted suicide

California governor signs bill legalising physician-assisted suicide

Sin, corruption and Islam: Justin Welby on the threats facing the Anglican Communion
Sin, corruption and Islam: Justin Welby on the threats facing the Anglican Communion

Sin, corruption and Islam: Justin Welby on the threats facing the Anglican Communion

Assisted suicide law looms in Canada to concern of Christian doctors
Assisted suicide law looms in Canada to concern of Christian doctors

Assisted suicide law looms in Canada to concern of Christian doctors

Legalised euthanasia: Christian doctors in Canada want \'conscience rights\' protected
Legalised euthanasia: Christian doctors in Canada want 'conscience rights' protected

Legalised euthanasia: Christian doctors in Canada want 'conscience rights' protected

BBC\'s decision to advertise suicide is a disgrace
BBC's decision to advertise suicide is a disgrace

BBC's decision to advertise suicide is a disgrace

Euthanasia in Holland: Loneliness cited as key motivator in majority of cases
Euthanasia in Holland: Loneliness cited as key motivator in majority of cases

Euthanasia in Holland: Loneliness cited as key motivator in majority of cases

Canadian government panel criticised for recommending euthanasia even for kids
Canadian government panel criticised for recommending euthanasia even for kids

Canadian government panel criticised for recommending euthanasia even for kids

Sick people who want to kill selves won\'t get last rites, Canadian archbishop says
Sick people who want to kill selves won't get last rites, Canadian archbishop says

Sick people who want to kill selves won't get last rites, Canadian archbishop says

\'Right to die\' debate hits Japan
'Right to die' debate hits Japan

'Right to die' debate hits Japan

Are Christian doctors allowed to conduct assisted deaths or suicides? Pastor John Piper answers \'slippery\' question
Are Christian doctors allowed to conduct assisted deaths or suicides? Pastor John Piper answers 'slippery' question

Are Christian doctors allowed to conduct assisted deaths or suicides? Pastor John Piper answers 'slippery' question

\'He\'s a mass killer\': After his own death, euthanasia activist confesses to illegally helping 8 people die
'He's a mass killer': After his own death, euthanasia activist confesses to illegally helping 8 people die

'He's a mass killer': After his own death, euthanasia activist confesses to illegally helping 8 people die

California set to become 5th state in U.S. to permit physician-assisted suicide
California set to become 5th state in U.S. to permit physician-assisted suicide

California set to become 5th state in U.S. to permit physician-assisted suicide

News
Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE
Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE

An independent review into the national curriculum for schools has highlighted the urgent need for standardised religious education (RE) across the country and greater subject specialism to ensure “mastery in the subject”. 

GP body shifts to ‘unwarranted and misleading’ neutral stance on assisted suicide despite declining support
GP body shifts to ‘unwarranted and misleading’ neutral stance on assisted suicide despite declining support

The Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) is facing criticism after changing from its longstanding opposition to assisted suicide to a neutral stance, despite a significant reduction in support among its members for legalising the practice.

Faith leaders pray for Trump
Faith leaders pray for Trump

Faith leaders have gathered to pray for President Trump, but not everyone is happy.

Rare pre-Reformation scroll to go on display in York
Rare pre-Reformation scroll to go on display in York

An extremely rare pre-Reformation scroll will go on display after being found in a shoebox.