Bishop and pastor face church trial for same-sex wedding

Bishop Melvin Talbert took part in a same-sex wedding ceremony. Reconciling Ministries Network

A pastor and a bishop of the United Methodist Church are facing disciplinary procedures because they officiated at a same-sex wedding on Saturday.

Bishop Melvin Talbert and Pastor Val Rosenquist officiated at the service for Jim Wilborne and John Romano. However, the UMC's Book of Discipline prohibits such services in spite of repeated efforts to rewrite it.

Talbert, who is 81 and retired, is a long-time campaigner against discrimination and in 1960 spent time in a cell with Martin Luther King.

He described his stance as an act of "biblical obedience".

Speaking at First United Methodist Church in Charlotte, North Carolina, he said: "Discrimination is discrimination, no matter where it is, and it's wrong. I hope that what we did here yesterday will be an act of evangelism for people...who are looking for safe places to come because they don't want to be identified with anti-gay [sentiment]."

He told the congregation: "Your pastor could have complaints filed against her, and I could, too." He added: "But it's the right thing to do. If it costs us, if there are consequences, so let it be."

Rosenquist, the church's senior pastor, said the UMC's Book of Discipline had "institutionalised oppression and discrimination". The church voted last August that it would sanction same-sex marriages whether it violated the UMC code or not.

She said of LGBT members: "These folks are our brothers and sisters. It's just a matter of obeying our covenant with one another throughout the church, that we are to minister to all and to treat all the same. I'm just following what I was ordained to do, what I was baptised to do."

A statement for the Charlotte Observer from the office of Bishop Larry Goodpaster, who leads the Western North Carolina Conference of the United Methodist Church, said: "We are aware of the wedding at First United Methodist Church on Saturday. Bishop Goodpaster will follow the procedures in The Book of Discipline if a formal complaint is filed."

Many US-based UMC ministers and congregations are relaxed about or in favour of same-sex marriage. However, though it has around 7 million members in the US, it it is an international denomination and moves to change its rules meet strong resistance from African countries and others with a conservative tradition.

Its General Conference starting on May 10 is to consider petitions repealing prohibitions on clergy conducting same-sex marriages.

related articles
Mississippi governor signs religious freedom law that allows denial of service to gay couples
Mississippi governor signs religious freedom law that allows denial of service to gay couples

Mississippi governor signs religious freedom law that allows denial of service to gay couples

Christians gather in D.C., L.A. in \'solemn assembly\' of unity to pray for America to return to God
Christians gather in D.C., L.A. in 'solemn assembly' of unity to pray for America to return to God

Christians gather in D.C., L.A. in 'solemn assembly' of unity to pray for America to return to God

Louisiana passes \'pastor protection bill\' deemed unnecessary by opponents
Louisiana passes 'pastor protection bill' deemed unnecessary by opponents

Louisiana passes 'pastor protection bill' deemed unnecessary by opponents

Why Christian ministers should stop taking weddings
Why Christian ministers should stop taking weddings

Why Christian ministers should stop taking weddings

News
Scots urged to reject ‘extreme’ assisted suicide legislation
Scots urged to reject ‘extreme’ assisted suicide legislation

Scottish voters are being urged to contact their MSPs ahead of a Stage One vote in Holyrood next week. 

Jeremy Clarkson warns Christianity is 'in danger' amid falling birth rates
Jeremy Clarkson warns Christianity is 'in danger' amid falling birth rates

Broadcaster and columnist Jeremy Clarkson has issued a stark warning about the future of Christianity, suggesting that a sharp decline in birth rates across the Western world could pose an existential threat to the faith’s long-term survival.

Trump denies any involvement in AI pope image amid Catholic backlash
Trump denies any involvement in AI pope image amid Catholic backlash

The controversy erupted just days before a historic Vatican conclave to elect the successor to Pope Francis.

More churches embrace AI in ministry but pastors prefer to write their own sermons - study
More churches embrace AI in ministry but pastors prefer to write their own sermons - study

More churches across the U.S. are embracing the use of Artificial Intelligence in their ministries, but pastors have stopped short of using the technology to prepare their sermons, data from the State of the Church Tech 2025 report shows.