California governor signs bill legalising physician-assisted suicide

California's Governor Jerry Brown signed an assisted suicide bill into law. Reuters

Physician-assisted suicide will become legal in California under a bill signed into law on Monday by Democratic Governor Jerry Brown, despite intense opposition from some religious and disability rights groups.

The law, based on a similar measure in Oregon, allows doctors to prescribe medication to end a patient's life if two doctors agree the person has only six months to live and is mentally competent.

In a rare statement accompanying the signing notice, Brown, a former Roman Catholic seminarian, said he closely considered arguments on both sides of the controversial measure, which makes California only the fifth US state to legalise assisted suicide for terminally ill patients.

"I do not know what I would do if I were dying in prolonged and excruciating pain," Brown said. "I am certain, however, that it would be a comfort to be able to consider the options afforded by this bill. And I wouldn't deny that right to others."

The law, which goes into effect January 1, makes it a felony to pressure anyone into requesting or taking assisted suicide drugs.

Advocates for physician-assisted suicide have tried for decades to persuade California to legalise the practice as a way to help end-stage cancer and other patients to die with less pain and suffering, failing six times in the legislature or the ballot box before finally winning passage last month.

article,article,article,article Related

The latest bill was introduced amid nationwide publicity over the case of Brittany Maynard, a 29-year-old brain cancer patient who moved from California to Oregon to take advantage of that state's assisted suicide law and died there.

"My wife, Brittany Maynard, spoke up last year to make a difference for terminally ill individuals who are facing a potentially harsh dying process," said Maynard's widower, Dan Diaz, who lobbied passionately for the bill when it was before the legislature.

The California bill was strongly opposed by some religious groups, including the Roman Catholic Church, as well as advocates for people with disabilities, who said unscrupulous caregivers or relatives could pressure vulnerable patients to take their own lives.

Law's protections questioned

Opponents also said the bill would invite insurance companies to take advantage of poor patients by offering to pay for the cost of life-ending drugs but not for the expensive treatments that could save lives.

"There is a deadly mix when you combine our broken healthcare system with assisted suicide, which immediately becomes the cheapest treatment," said Marilyn Golden, a senior policy analyst at the Disability Rights Education & Defense Fund in Berkeley. "The so-called protections written into the bill really amount to very little."

But supporters said the measure would allow people who are terminally ill to die with dignity and greater comfort.

"My daughter did not die in vain," said Dr Robert Olvera, an advocate for the measure whose daughter succumbed to leukaemia in 2014. "This is the option she wanted to end her suffering."

As presently written, the law will expire after 10 years unless extended, a compromise with lawmakers who were worried about unintended consequences such as the targeting of the poor, elderly and disabled.

Physician-assisted suicide is already legal in the states of Oregon, Washington, Montana and Vermont.

On Monday, the advocacy group Compassion and Choices, which backed and lobbied for the measure, called on other states to follow California's lead.

Opponents were quick to react, saying that passage in other states was far from inevitable.

Tim Rosales, a spokesman for Californians Against Assisted Suicide, said his coalition had not yet decided whether it would sue to stop the new law from going into effect.

But he downplayed the likelihood that advocates would be able to quickly mount campaigns in other states, saying it would be difficult for them to raise enough money to go state by state and fight for such a controversial proposal.

related articles
Posthumous footage of right-to-die campaigner Brittany Maynard released
Posthumous footage of right-to-die campaigner Brittany Maynard released

Posthumous footage of right-to-die campaigner Brittany Maynard released

California assisted suicide bill advances in special session
California assisted suicide bill advances in special session

California assisted suicide bill advances in special session

Assisted dying devalues life, warns Archbishop of Canterbury
Assisted dying devalues life, warns Archbishop of Canterbury

Assisted dying devalues life, warns Archbishop of Canterbury

MPs vote overwhelmingly against assisted dying
MPs vote overwhelmingly against assisted dying

MPs vote overwhelmingly against assisted dying

News
Christian teacher who said being LGBT was a sin loses High Court challenge
Christian teacher who said being LGBT was a sin loses High Court challenge

The High Court has upheld the dismissal of a Christian teacher who told pupils at the London school where she worked that being LGBT was a sin. 

Christian nurse launches legal action after investigation for calling convicted transgender paedophile ‘Mr’ 
Christian nurse launches legal action after investigation for calling convicted transgender paedophile ‘Mr’ 

A Christian senior nurse was investigated and deemed “a potential risk” after she referred to a convicted transgender child sex offender as ‘Mr’. 

AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?
AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?

The relationship between faith and storytelling has always been central to Christianity. From the parables of Jesus to grand cinematic adaptations of biblical narratives, each generation has found new ways to bring Scripture to life. 

Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE
Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE

An independent review into the national curriculum for schools has highlighted the urgent need for standardised religious education (RE) across the country and greater subject specialism to ensure “mastery in the subject”.