Catholic Church in India should end 'silence' over kidnapped Dalit bishop, say critics

Bishop of Cuddapah Prasad Gallela with Archbishop of Kansas City Joseph Naumann at a mass of dedication in 2013 following the renovation of St Peter and St Paul church in Kansas in the US. St Peter and St Paul Church, Kansas

The Catholic Church hierarchy in India has been accused of ignoring an attack on a Dalit bishop after three of its own priests were arrested in connection with the attack.

Bishop of Cuddapah Prasad Gallela, of the so-called "untouchable" Dalit caste, and his driver Vijay Kumar were kidnapped in April this year, blindfolded and beaten and taken to an undisclosed place where £50,000 was demanded in ransom.

Three high-caste priests were among those arrested for the crime. 

The South India Dalit Catholic Association has now condemned the Catholic hierarchy's "silence", UCA reported. In a statement, the association condems the "silence of the official church on the kidnapping and assault of Bishop Prasad Gallela by three priests of the Cudappa Diocese on 25 April."

Jesuit Priest Father AXJ Bosco, a Dalit activist in the area, sent an open letter to the president of the national Catholic bishops' conference, Cardinal Baselios Cleemis of Trivandrum, criticising the silence.

"The sad and criminal event has been published in the media," he wrote, asking why there had been "no significant response condemning the culprit priests or supporting Gallela" in the national media.

He said: "Are all the prayers, statements, promises and assurances of the hierarchy and Church leaders only in words? Is the Church leadership afraid of their caste communities; or do they not care about the Dalits even if they happen to be bishops?

"You can very well imagine what the people, especially the Dalit Catholics, would think and feel about the significant silence on the part of the official Church.

"We know that there is caste discrimination in the Church, and it is a great challenge to the Christian Community in India.

"The question to ask is - If Jesus were here, what he would have done?"

Bosco called for a "concrete" plan of action, including transfer of bishops to other dioceses when they refuse to treat Dalits as equals. 

In May this year, Gallela was supported by a rally in Kadapa city in south-east India, Crux reported.

Discrimination based on caste system is illegal in India but it has proved almost impossible to eradicate.

A Capuchin Franciscan priest, Father Nithiya Sagayam, told Crux that the Church should speak out more on the caste system: "The silence of the official Church is criminal."

He added: "Our socially discriminatory society is vigorously condemned by secular leaders who work for social justice. It is shocking that the Catholic Church and its official organisations have not responded effectively to end this evil, in spite of clear indications of caste discrimination within the Church leadership."

Gallela's attackers took three ATM cards, a silver chain with the bishop's holy cross and his iPhone.

From 2000 to 2004, Gallela served as a priest in the diocese of San Angelo, Texas, before returning to India to teach in a local seminary.

related articles
Upsurge in Violence across India Ahead of International Day of Prayer

Upsurge in Violence across India Ahead of International Day of Prayer

India's Supreme Court delays Dalit Christian hearings

India's Supreme Court delays Dalit Christian hearings

Kidnapped bishop handcuffed and beaten then released
Kidnapped bishop handcuffed and beaten then released

Kidnapped bishop handcuffed and beaten then released

Bishop\'s own priests among men arrested for his assault and kidnapping
Bishop's own priests among men arrested for his assault and kidnapping

Bishop's own priests among men arrested for his assault and kidnapping

News
UK Christian charities help raise over £10m for Myanmar earthquake survivors
UK Christian charities help raise over £10m for Myanmar earthquake survivors

A powerful wave of compassion from across the UK has helped raise more than £10m for the people of Myanmar, devastated by a 7.7 magnitude earthquake that hit on 28th March 2025, claiming over 3,000 and leaving many more injured and displaced.

Church of England invests millions in parish renewal and mission expansion
Church of England invests millions in parish renewal and mission expansion

In a major funding boost aimed at revitalising local churches and expanding outreach efforts, the Church of England has announced a new wave of grants supporting parishes across both urban and rural communities. 

Lottery gives £1.69m grant to restore Pugin designs in Nottingham Cathedral
Lottery gives £1.69m grant to restore Pugin designs in Nottingham Cathedral

The grant is part of the cathedral's Restoring Pugin Project

Half of Gaza's Christians hiding in one church
Half of Gaza's Christians hiding in one church

Those who have survived consider themselves lucky