Church asks U.S. federal court to stop Iowa from enforcing transgender bathroom rules even inside churches

A gender-neutral bathroom is seen at the University of California, Irvine in Irvine, California. Reuters

A church in Iowa is asking a federal court to stop the state's civil rights commission from enforcing a law that prohibits bathroom discrimination based on sexual orientation or gender identity.

The Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) submitted the motion last week on behalf of the Fort Des Moines Church of Christ in Des Moines aimed at stopping the commission "from censoring the church's teaching on biblical sexuality and from forcing the church to open its restrooms and showers to members of the opposite sex."

A brochure issued by the commission states that places of worship like churches and synagogues "are generally exempt from the Iowa law's prohibition of discrimination, unless the place of worship engages in non-religious activities which are open to the public" such as an independent day care centre or polling place that are on the premises.

But the ADF legal counsel Christiana Holcomb said, "Churches should be free to communicate their religious beliefs and operate their houses of worship according to their faith without fearing government punishment, and until the law is changed, every church in Iowa has a right to be concerned."

"No state or local law should threaten the foundational First Amendment protections for free speech and the free exercise of religion," she said.

On the same day the motion was filed, Commissioner Peter Kirsanow of the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights, sent a letter to Iowa Civil Rights Commission (ICRC) Chairperson Angela Jackson, saying that the "approach taken by the ICRC plainly violates both the Free Exercise Clause and the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment of the United States Constitution."

Iowa's law bans places of public accommodation from expressing view on human sexuality if they would "directly or indirectly" make "persons of any particular...gender identity" feel "unwelcome," the ADF said.

The ADF said the speech ban could be used to gag churches from making public comments including from the pulpit that could be interpreted as unwelcome to certain persons.

Under the law, transgenders can use bathrooms, locker rooms and living facilities according to their gender identity.

The ADF argues that all events held at a church on its property have bona fide religious purpose and the commission cannot violate the First Amendment's guarantee of freedom of religion and speech.

"The act's coercive demands harm the church's ability to teach its doctrines, to govern itself, and to follow its faith without fear that the government will overstep its bounds and impose illegitimate requirements," said ADF senior counsel Steven O'Ban.

related articles
U.S. transgender row: School district freezes fed bathroom policy after father pulls out 3 sons from school over issue
U.S. transgender row: School district freezes fed bathroom policy after father pulls out 3 sons from school over issue

U.S. transgender row: School district freezes fed bathroom policy after father pulls out 3 sons from school over issue

New York City launches major ad campaign to promote use of public bathrooms based on gender identity
New York City launches major ad campaign to promote use of public bathrooms based on gender identity

New York City launches major ad campaign to promote use of public bathrooms based on gender identity

Man admits using Target, Starbucks bathrooms to help women get pregnant
Man admits using Target, Starbucks bathrooms to help women get pregnant

Man admits using Target, Starbucks bathrooms to help women get pregnant

Transgender files appeal after court rejects plea to change her name from Elizabeth to Elijah, saying \'it\'s a type of fraud\'
Transgender files appeal after court rejects plea to change her name from Elizabeth to Elijah, saying 'it's a type of fraud'

Transgender files appeal after court rejects plea to change her name from Elizabeth to Elijah, saying 'it's a type of fraud'

Kansas education board votes to ignore Obama\'s transgender bathroom policy
Kansas education board votes to ignore Obama's transgender bathroom policy

Kansas education board votes to ignore Obama's transgender bathroom policy

United Methodist Church nominates three openly gay clergy to be bishops
United Methodist Church nominates three openly gay clergy to be bishops

United Methodist Church nominates three openly gay clergy to be bishops

U.S. federal court blocks new Mississippi law that seeks to protect people\'s freedom of conscience
U.S. federal court blocks new Mississippi law that seeks to protect people's freedom of conscience

U.S. federal court blocks new Mississippi law that seeks to protect people's freedom of conscience

Britain\'s Methodist Church to consider same-sex marriage
Britain's Methodist Church to consider same-sex marriage

Britain's Methodist Church to consider same-sex marriage

More US states sue Obama administration over transgender directive
More US states sue Obama administration over transgender directive

More US states sue Obama administration over transgender directive

New York human rights panel upholds women-only hours policy at public pools to accommodate religious beliefs
New York human rights panel upholds women-only hours policy at public pools to accommodate religious beliefs

New York human rights panel upholds women-only hours policy at public pools to accommodate religious beliefs

Chaplains express religious liberty concern over Pentagon\'s repeal of transgender ban in military
Chaplains express religious liberty concern over Pentagon's repeal of transgender ban in military

Chaplains express religious liberty concern over Pentagon's repeal of transgender ban in military

Target fitting room controversy: Man, transgender woman arrested for filming girls in dressing rooms
Target fitting room controversy: Man, transgender woman arrested for filming girls in dressing rooms

Target fitting room controversy: Man, transgender woman arrested for filming girls in dressing rooms

Evangelical victimhood: Why we should challenge the narrative
Evangelical victimhood: Why we should challenge the narrative

Evangelical victimhood: Why we should challenge the narrative

Majority of US evangelical Christians have moral problem with gender reassignment
Majority of US evangelical Christians have moral problem with gender reassignment

Majority of US evangelical Christians have moral problem with gender reassignment

Deep divisions over homosexuality as UMC elects first openly gay bishop
Deep divisions over homosexuality as UMC elects first openly gay bishop

Deep divisions over homosexuality as UMC elects first openly gay bishop

News
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme

The document outlines the governing priorities of Northern Ireland’s government.

Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'
Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'

In his weekly Angelus address, Pope Francis gave praise to God as the one who never abandons us, even in times of severe trial.

Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector
Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector

Serhy Semchuk was sentenced to five years and has had all appeals rejected

Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church
Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church

A homeless man alleged to have threatened a deadly gas attack on Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church in Houston, Texas, on Christmas Eve has been indicted on a federal terrorism charge.