Contraceptive implants for female inmates in U.S. raise ethical questions: Did they have a choice?

Maricopa County female inmates march for chain gang duty in Phoenix, Arizona in this file photo. Reuters

Is this just an honest to goodness programme to teach female prisoners contraception or the alarming resurgence of eugenics, the practice of reducing birth rates of individuals with less desirable traits?

The state of Tennessee recently launched an ambitious programme which involves the implantation of contraceptive rods or intrauterine devices (IUDs) in female prison inmates from 15 counties. A medical practitioner and a pro-life advocate, however, warned that this programme may be violating ethical standards.

In an interview with LifeSite News, Human Life International's Stephen Phelan warned that in the past, the racist practice of eugenics was peddled as something that was for the "best interests" of the victim.

"Coercion isn't only literally forcing one to do something against her will," Phelan said. "It can also be pressuring her to take a certain course without providing all information and time to make a free decision."

Dr. Annette Mendola, director of clinical ethics for the University of Tennessee's Graduate School of Medicine, meanwhile said the state should make sure that the female prisoners are indeed given sufficient information and choice in relation to the contraceptive programme.

"If done badly, it could be horribly coercive. You want to make sure people feel like they have a choice," Mendola also told LifeSite News.

The Tennessee state government started the contraceptive implantation programme in Sevier County, where female prisoners began receiving abortifacient IUDs at no cost.

According to county officials, female prisoners become the subject of this state-funded contraceptive effort because they often have a history of drug abuse, which makes them supposedly "less receptive" to getting and using long-acting contraception.

Officials also said that incarcerated women provide a captive and sober audience for the contraceptive programme.

In Knox County, meanwhile, health officials even contact women from prison after their release to check on the implanted contraceptives.

related articles
Abortions in New York decrease 21% since 2008 as more women opt not to undergo procedure
Abortions in New York decrease 21% since 2008 as more women opt not to undergo procedure

Abortions in New York decrease 21% since 2008 as more women opt not to undergo procedure

Pope Francis\' \'The Joy of Love\' treatise on marriage and family draws mixed reaction
Pope Francis' 'The Joy of Love' treatise on marriage and family draws mixed reaction

Pope Francis' 'The Joy of Love' treatise on marriage and family draws mixed reaction

\'Consequences\' imposed on US church by Anglican primates have been \'fully implemented\' says Archbishop
'Consequences' imposed on US church by Anglican primates have been 'fully implemented' says Archbishop

'Consequences' imposed on US church by Anglican primates have been 'fully implemented' says Archbishop

U.S. government admits it doesn\'t need to force religious organisations to provide contraceptives
U.S. government admits it doesn't need to force religious organisations to provide contraceptives

U.S. government admits it doesn't need to force religious organisations to provide contraceptives

Top abortion advocate Cecile Richards gets standing ovation at Georgetown, oldest U.S. Catholic university
Top abortion advocate Cecile Richards gets standing ovation at Georgetown, oldest U.S. Catholic university

Top abortion advocate Cecile Richards gets standing ovation at Georgetown, oldest U.S. Catholic university

US Catholics like the Pope, but don\'t listen to him
US Catholics like the Pope, but don't listen to him

US Catholics like the Pope, but don't listen to him

News
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme

The document outlines the governing priorities of Northern Ireland’s government.

Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'
Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'

In his weekly Angelus address, Pope Francis gave praise to God as the one who never abandons us, even in times of severe trial.

Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector
Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector

Serhy Semchuk was sentenced to five years and has had all appeals rejected

Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church
Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church

A homeless man alleged to have threatened a deadly gas attack on Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church in Houston, Texas, on Christmas Eve has been indicted on a federal terrorism charge.