Evangelical Alliance slams 'disproportionate' church singing ban

 (Photo: Unsplash/Aaron Burden)

The Evangelical Alliance has hit out at "nonsensical" and "discriminatory" rules around congregational singing in churches. 

Writing on the group's website, the EA's advocacy lead, Danny Webster, said the current ban was "inconsistent", "disproportionate" and contradicted the evidence.

Restrictions vary across the UK. In Scotland, indoor congregational singing is permitted in parts of the country with fewer Covid cases, but is limited to a small group of performers in regions under tougher restrictions. 

In Wales, rules were relaxed over the weekend so that churches can once again sing together inside their buildings. 

In England, indoor singing during services continues to be restricted to only a small group of performers.

Webster said that out of all the Covid rules for places of worship, the ban on congregational singing "grates the most", and that seeing large crowds singing and chanting during Euro 2020 matches had been an "added insult for churches".

"In England, the rules are more nonsensical because professional performers are not limited numerically so you could have a choir of hundreds sing, whereas for amateur singers the cap is at 6," he said.

"The government has not produced evidence to explain why singing by amateurs is more likely to spread coronavirus than by professionals."

He later added, "I do not realistically expect the government to stop fans from cheering, and trains and planes of Scottish fans descending on London were never going to be silent, but I would like to see some humility that in requiring churches to continue to mute their congregation the government are permitting football fans to do something they are not extending to worship services." 

The government has defended the ban on the grounds of concerns around aerosol transmission during singing, but Wesbter pointed to evidence from the CONFESS study by UCL which suggests that masks reduce aerosol dispersal by 85 per cent. 

"While only one study, this demonstrates a clear direction of evidence, and the government appear unwilling to rethink their policy position when new evidence appears," Webster said. 

News
On striving for destiny
On striving for destiny

Hebrew scholar and Jewish academic Irene Lancaster reflects on Numbers, leadership and destiny. 

Divorce at 50-year low despite liberalising reforms
Divorce at 50-year low despite liberalising reforms

The Marriage Foundation has welcomed figures from the Office for National Statistics (ONS), saying they show that marriages are the strongest they have been for 50 years.

Pope Leo XIV calls for global solidarity with Eastern Churches amid conflict and crisis
Pope Leo XIV calls for global solidarity with Eastern Churches amid conflict and crisis

“How can we think that we are laying the foundations of the future apart from cooperation and a global vision inspired by the common good?"

British media preoccupied with Catholic Church - report
British media preoccupied with Catholic Church - report

A study into media coverage of Christianity in Britain has showed that coverage is more likely to take a negative tone towards the faith and is arguably biased towards coverage of the Roman Catholic Church.