Florida court junks atheist group's lawsuit on alleged state aid for prison ministries

Members of the Prisoners of Christ Ministry pose outside their office in Jacksonville, Florida. (Becket Fund)

A Florida circuit court has dismissed an eight-year lawsuit filed by an atheist group that sought to stop state funding to two faith-based prison ministries under a government programme that rehabilitates former prisoners from drug and alcohol addiction.

The Center for Inquiry originally filed the lawsuit in 2007 against the Florida Department of Corrections to stop its contracts with Lamb of God Ministries and Prisoners of Christ Ministry, saying it violated Florida Constitution's "No Aid" provision which states that "no revenue of the state or any political subdivision or agency thereof shall ever be taken from the public treasury directly or indirectly in aid of any church, sect, or religious denomination or in aid of any sectarian institution."

"Lamb of God and Prisoners of Christ both openly describe themselves as Christian ministries, and engage in explicitly sectarian religious practices," according to the Center's Ronald Lindsay, the Christian News Network reported. "The people of Florida shouldn't have their tax dollars used for religious purposes."

It filed another lawsuit last year in its attempt to permanently cut off Florida's funding to the two organisations.

The lawsuit accused the two organisations of "actively advancing religion within their faith-based recovery programs."

"Although participation in the most prominent religious portions of the programs—the prayer meetings—is ostensibly voluntary (though strongly encouraged), enrollees are nevertheless required to participate in programs built around Christian faith," it said.

In its decision on Wednesday, the Circuit Court of Leon County, Florida, dismissed the lawsuit, saying the rehabilitation programmes offered by the two ministries are not "significantly sectarian."

"Plaintiffs have submitted no evidence that State funds are expended on religious activities or content," the court ruled. "Instead, the record shows that the State funds are intended to cover the amount spent on housing, utilities, and insurance—though the funds do not quite cover all of those costs. Further, to the extent any religious content is provided at all, that content is wholly optional for the Program participants."

The court added that "under the undisputed facts of this case, based on eight years of litigation and a lengthy record, Plaintiffs have not demonstrated that state funds are being unconstitutionally used."

Becket Fund, which represented the defendants, hailed the decision, saying, "The Court was right to reject a discriminatory attempt to punish successful prisoner ministries simply because they were run by religiously-inspired people."

"It's a pity that the ministries and the men they serve had to wait on pins and needles for nearly a decade because an activist group—who had no interest in helping prisoners or providing alternatives—had nothing better to do than try to bully a successful program out of existence," said Becket Fund's Lori Windham on Thursday.

related articles
Atheist files lawsuit to remove \'In God We Trust\' from U.S. currency, claiming that it violates First Amendment
Atheist files lawsuit to remove 'In God We Trust' from U.S. currency, claiming that it violates First Amendment

Atheist files lawsuit to remove 'In God We Trust' from U.S. currency, claiming that it violates First Amendment

U.S. military health officer draws complaint for writing blog post promoting prayer
U.S. military health officer draws complaint for writing blog post promoting prayer

U.S. military health officer draws complaint for writing blog post promoting prayer

California court rules Catholic hospital can\'t be forced to perform tubal ligation
California court rules Catholic hospital can't be forced to perform tubal ligation

California court rules Catholic hospital can't be forced to perform tubal ligation

Christians face obscene persecution – let\'s not be afraid to say so
Christians face obscene persecution – let's not be afraid to say so

Christians face obscene persecution – let's not be afraid to say so

Obama says he seeks to preserve religious liberty — but some Christians believe he\'s doing the opposite
Obama says he seeks to preserve religious liberty — but some Christians believe he's doing the opposite

Obama says he seeks to preserve religious liberty — but some Christians believe he's doing the opposite

Church leader and democracy advocate could face life in prison after arrest in China
Church leader and democracy advocate could face life in prison after arrest in China

Church leader and democracy advocate could face life in prison after arrest in China

Duggar pastor Ronnie Floyd tells Christians what to do when their faith is put to the test
Duggar pastor Ronnie Floyd tells Christians what to do when their faith is put to the test

Duggar pastor Ronnie Floyd tells Christians what to do when their faith is put to the test

Faith leaders to hold conference on rights of religious minorities in Muslim countries
Faith leaders to hold conference on rights of religious minorities in Muslim countries

Faith leaders to hold conference on rights of religious minorities in Muslim countries

West Virginia lawmakers push religious freedom bill despite governor\'s veto threat
West Virginia lawmakers push religious freedom bill despite governor's veto threat

West Virginia lawmakers push religious freedom bill despite governor's veto threat

News
Wet feet: Taking the first step of faith
Wet feet: Taking the first step of faith

Faith is often accompanied by uncertainty, yet it is in stepping forward that we encounter the power of God. The Israelites learned this at the Jordan River, where God performed a miracle only after they demonstrated obedience. 

When New Year’s Day used to be on 25 March
When New Year’s Day used to be on 25 March

When New Year’s Day used to be on 25 March25 March is known as Lady Day, also known as the Annunciation of the Lord, and it used to be the old New Year’s Day.  This is the story …

Astronaut says faith in Jesus sustained him through 9 months stranded in space
Astronaut says faith in Jesus sustained him through 9 months stranded in space

NASA astronaut Butch Wilmore, who was trapped aboard the International Space Station for 9 months with fellow astronaut, Suni Williams, is attributing his endurance during the mission to one thing above all - his faith in Jesus Christ.

UK faith leaders urge government to be ‘bold and ambitious’ in Child Poverty Strategy
UK faith leaders urge government to be ‘bold and ambitious’ in Child Poverty Strategy

In a show of unity, 35 senior faith leaders from across the UK have appealed to the government to take a “bold, and ambitious” approach in its upcoming Child Poverty Strategy.