'Gay cake' case: Appeal begins today, as Ashers Bakery insists it does not discriminate

A court appeal launched by Christian-run Ashers Bakery over the so-called "gay cake case" is due to begin today.

Daniel McArthur, general manager of Ashers, arrived at the High Court in Belfast this morning with his wife Amy to begin a two-day hearing. The couple are seeking to overturn a decision against them over their refusal to produce a cake with a "support gay marriage" slogan for LGBT activist Gareth Lee.

They were fined £500 after Judge Brownlie ruled their decision amounted to discrimination under laws which prohibit the refusal of services on the grounds of religion, race, or sexual orientation.

Daniel McArthur does not have the right to "manifest" his faith in a commercial setting, according to the previous ruling by Judge Brownlie. The appeal will be heard today. The Christian Institute

"Ashers does not discriminate against anyone," Daniel McArthur told journalists outside the court this morning.

"We took issue with the message on the cake not the customer. As a family we believe we should retain the freedom to decline business that would require us to promote a cause with which we disagree."

However the chief commissioner of the Equalities Commission, which launched the legal challenge on behalf of Lee, said Ashers Bakery had been discriminatory.

article,article,article,article Related

"One of the things the Equality Commission does is support people who we believe have been discriminated against," said Dr Michael Wardlow this morning. "When it raises a strategic issue, that allows us to challenge discriminatory practice and raise awareness of the legislation.

"In this particular case we believe this has happened. We hope today the three judges will agree and Judge Brownlie's ruling will stand."

The case was highlighted after prominent LGBT rights activist, Peter Tatchell, announced his support for the McArthurs' right to free speech.

"Much as I wish to defend the gay community, I also want to defend freedom of conscience, expression and religion," he wrote in an article for the Guardian.

A petition supporting the McArthurs was launched by their legal backers, the Christian Institute, in January and now has over 9,000 signatories.

The appeal will likely be heard for two days with a ruling delivered on Thursday.

related articles
Ashers manager: \'We don\'t think we\'ve done anything wrong\'
Ashers manager: 'We don't think we've done anything wrong'

Ashers manager: 'We don't think we've done anything wrong'

Ashers\' Bakery: The real loser here is a tolerant society
Ashers' Bakery: The real loser here is a tolerant society

Ashers' Bakery: The real loser here is a tolerant society

Leading gay rights campaigner supports Ashers Bakery in \'gay cake\' row
Leading gay rights campaigner supports Ashers Bakery in 'gay cake' row

Leading gay rights campaigner supports Ashers Bakery in 'gay cake' row

Ashers Bakery petition tops 8,000 as \'gay cake\' appeal looms
Ashers Bakery petition tops 8,000 as 'gay cake' appeal looms

Ashers Bakery petition tops 8,000 as 'gay cake' appeal looms

News
AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?
AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?

The relationship between faith and storytelling has always been central to Christianity. From the parables of Jesus to grand cinematic adaptations of biblical narratives, each generation has found new ways to bring Scripture to life. 

Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE
Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE

An independent review into the national curriculum for schools has highlighted the urgent need for standardised religious education (RE) across the country and greater subject specialism to ensure “mastery in the subject”. 

GP body shifts to ‘unwarranted and misleading’ neutral stance on assisted suicide despite declining support
GP body shifts to ‘unwarranted and misleading’ neutral stance on assisted suicide despite declining support

The Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) is facing criticism after changing from its longstanding opposition to assisted suicide to a neutral stance, despite a significant reduction in support among its members for legalising the practice.

Faith leaders pray for Trump
Faith leaders pray for Trump

Faith leaders have gathered to pray for President Trump, but not everyone is happy.