Humanist asylum seeker turned away after he didn't know about Greek philosophers

A Pakistani man who left Islam to become a humanist has been denied asylum in the UK after failing to correctly answer questions about ancient Greek philosophers.

Hamza bin Walayat's failure to identify Plato and Aristotle as humanist philosophers indicated his knowledge of humanism was 'rudimentary at best', the Home Office said according to the Guardian.

The Home Office also denied Walayat's claim he faced persecution in Pakistan for converting away from Islam and that his family could kill him.

A Methodist church in Pakistan was bombed by extremists in December. Reuters

The rejection letter, seen by the Guardian, said Walayat's claims were unfounded and he had 'been unable to provide a consistent or credible account with regards the main aspect of your claim, namely that you are a humanist'.

He gave a 'basic definition' when tested on his knowledge of humanism but could not identify 'any famous Greek philosophers who were humanistic'.

According to the Guardian, the letter said: 'When you were informed by the interviewing officer that he was referring to Plato and Aristotle, you replied: "Yeah, the thing is because of my medication that is strong I just forget stuff sometimes."'

The Home Office ruled: 'Your knowledge of humanism is rudimentary at best and not of a level that would be expected of a genuine follower of humanism.'

Walayat has lived in the UK since 2011 and said he had received death threats from his family in Pakistan because of his decision to leave Islam and start a relationship with a non-Muslim.

In Pakistan blasphemy is punishable by death and mob violence can lead to extra-judicial killings if someone is perceived to have left or insulted Islam.

Andrew Copson, of Humanists UK, said the move 'set a dangerous precedent for non-religious people fleeing persecution. The Home Office is simply incorrect to claim that non-religious people seeking asylum don't get the same protection in law as religious people do.'

Home Office officials 'reveal a fundamental misunderstanding about the nature of humanism', he added.

It comes after the Home Office was found to be rejecting Christian asylum seekers who could not name all Ten Commandments. One asylum seeker even said he was asked what colour a Bible was in his interview for asylum in the UK

A Home Office spokesperson said: 'The UK has a proud history of granting asylum to those who need our protection and each claim is carefully considered on its individual merits.'

News
Calls for urgent policy reforms to address widening marriage gap between rich and poor
Calls for urgent policy reforms to address widening marriage gap between rich and poor

A new report released by the Marriage Foundation has called for urgent policy changes by the government to address what it describes as a "calamitous" marriage gap of 51 per cent between wealthy and low-income couples.

Bear Grylls talks about faith in spite of doubts at Flame 2025
Bear Grylls talks about faith in spite of doubts at Flame 2025

Grylls described faith as an adventure and a journey.

Bible sales surge by 87% as Generation Z rediscovers faith
Bible sales surge by 87% as Generation Z rediscovers faith

Bible sales in the UK have risen sharply, increasing by 87 per cent from £2.69 million in 2019 to £5.02 million in 2024, according to new data from SPCK Group and Nielsen Book Data.

Lent and Ramadan have sparked complaints over the ‘woke’ storyline in BBC Radio drama The Archers
Lent and Ramadan have sparked complaints over the ‘woke’ storyline in BBC Radio drama The Archers

BBC Radio 4’s long-running rural drama The Archers has come under fire for its recent exploration of Ramadan, with many listeners criticising the decision to feature a Christian character, Lynda Snell, fasting in the run-up to Lent.