Lawyers for Charleston church shooter Dylann Roof challenge federal trial, seek dropping of death penalty

Dylann Roof (R), the 21-year-old man charged with murdering nine worshippers at a historic black church in Charleston last month, listens to the proceedings with assistant defense attorney William Maguire during a hearing at the Judicial Center in Charleston, South Carolina in this July 16, 2015 file photo. Reuters

Lawyers for Dylann Roof, the suspect in the shooting and killing of nine people inside the Emanuel AME Church in Charleston, South Carolina in June last year, are challenging the federal hate crimes law which their client has been accused of breaking even as they seek to convince prosecutors not to pursue the death penalty.

Roof's defence team said the hate crimes stature "affords the federal government virtually unchecked discretion to prosecute crimes already being punished by the states," the Associated Press reports.

The 22-year-old suspect is facing 33 federal violations including hate crimes and obstructing the practice of religion. Roof allegedly told a friend that he wanted to start a race war.

His lawyers previously said that Roof would plead guilty if death penalty is not included. Prosecutors are given until July 25 to respond.

Roof's federal trial will begin in November and defence lawyers may try to "derail the trial" unless the judge orders that jury members be chosen from a state-wide pool, prosecutors said in a court filing.

"The government requests this Court use a (pool of potential jurors drawn from across South Carolina)," said federal prosecutors, according to The State, adding that the reason is "to ensure that the scheduled trial not be interrupted."

Until recently, the jury was expected to have been chosen from a Lowcounty jury pool, where members would come from Charleston and eight other counties.

Assistant U.S. attorneys Jay Richardson and Nathan Williams told Judge Richard Gergel that Roof's lawyers may try "an 11th-hour attempt" to change the jury pool to a state-wide pool that could delay the trial.

Prosecutors also said defence attorneys might make a last-minute request to change the trial's location from Charleston.

They also said that without a state-wide jury pool, it will be harder to choose "a fair and impartial" jury as "most of the parishioners who were murdered and those who survived Roof's attack ... have strong ties to the Charleston area."

The judge will hold a hearing on July 18 to decide on the location and manner of jury selection.

related articles
Charleston shooting church to bless families and survivors with $1.5m
Charleston shooting church to bless families and survivors with $1.5m

Charleston shooting church to bless families and survivors with $1.5m

Emanuel AME Church appoints new woman pastor since June shooting that killed 9
Emanuel AME Church appoints new woman pastor since June shooting that killed 9

Emanuel AME Church appoints new woman pastor since June shooting that killed 9

Donald Trump and Emanuel AME Church among Nobel Peace Prize nominations
Donald Trump and Emanuel AME Church among Nobel Peace Prize nominations

Donald Trump and Emanuel AME Church among Nobel Peace Prize nominations

Charleston massacre: Dylann Roof trial delayed over death penalty decision
Charleston massacre: Dylann Roof trial delayed over death penalty decision

Charleston massacre: Dylann Roof trial delayed over death penalty decision

Pastor urges Southern Baptist Convention to stop displaying Confederate flag
Pastor urges Southern Baptist Convention to stop displaying Confederate flag

Pastor urges Southern Baptist Convention to stop displaying Confederate flag

Friend of Charleston church shooting suspect pleads guilty to lying
Friend of Charleston church shooting suspect pleads guilty to lying

Friend of Charleston church shooting suspect pleads guilty to lying

Charleston massacre: We will seek death penalty for Dylann Roof, say prosecutors
Charleston massacre: We will seek death penalty for Dylann Roof, say prosecutors

Charleston massacre: We will seek death penalty for Dylann Roof, say prosecutors

Charleston church massacre: One year on, congregation \'focuses on God\'
Charleston church massacre: One year on, congregation 'focuses on God'

Charleston church massacre: One year on, congregation 'focuses on God'

Amazing Grace: One year on from the Charleston church shooting
Amazing Grace: One year on from the Charleston church shooting

Amazing Grace: One year on from the Charleston church shooting

Charleston church marks a year since devastating shooting
Charleston church marks a year since devastating shooting

Charleston church marks a year since devastating shooting

Charleston church massacre survivors sue FBI for allowing shooter Dylann Roof to buy a gun despite drug use admission
Charleston church massacre survivors sue FBI for allowing shooter Dylann Roof to buy a gun despite drug use admission

Charleston church massacre survivors sue FBI for allowing shooter Dylann Roof to buy a gun despite drug use admission

News
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme

The document outlines the governing priorities of Northern Ireland’s government.

Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'
Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'

In his weekly Angelus address, Pope Francis gave praise to God as the one who never abandons us, even in times of severe trial.

Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector
Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector

Serhy Semchuk was sentenced to five years and has had all appeals rejected

Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church
Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church

A homeless man alleged to have threatened a deadly gas attack on Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church in Houston, Texas, on Christmas Eve has been indicted on a federal terrorism charge.