Methodist church investigates pastor who conducted same-sex wedding

The retired Bishop Melvin Talbert took part in a same-sex wedding ceremony. Reconciling Ministries Network

A formal complaint has been filed against a Methodist minister who conducted a same-sex wedding in North Carolina on Saturday.

Bishop Melvin Talbert and Pastor Val Rosenquist conducted the service for Jim Wilborne and John Romano in direct contradiction to the United Methodist Church's (UMC) teaching. The anonymous complaint will be investigated by the local bishop Larry Goodpaster.

Goodpaster leads the Western North Carolina Conference of the UMC and a statement from officials acknowledged a same-sex wedding would be in violation of the church's teaching, called the Book of Discipline.

Pastor Valerie Rosenquist issenior pastor at Charlotte First United Methodist Church Charlotte First United Methodist Church

Rosenquist said she was not surprised by the complaint but said she was willing to face consequences in order to put pressure on church officials. Both Rosenquist and Talbert described the service as "an act of biblical obedience".

Talbert, who is 81 and retired, is a long-time campaigner against discrimination and in 1960 spent time in a cell with Martin Luther King.

He said: "Discrimination is discrimination, no matter where it is, and it's wrong. I hope that what we did here will be an act of evangelism for people...who are looking for safe places to come because they don't want to be identified with anti-gay [sentiment]."

Michael Rich, a spokesperson for the Western North Carolina Conference, said details of the investigation are "a confidential matter, and [the bishop] is not going to speak about it."

The dispute comes at a poignant time for the UMC as next month its international voting body will consider whether to repeal the current ban on clergy conducting same-sex weddings. Many of the US-based UMC ministers are relaxed about same-sex marriage services.

However it has yet to follow The Episcopal Church in the US. This is largely because it is an interational denomination and increasing move to change the rules are blocked by ministers from more conservative African countries.

related articles
United Methodist pastor faces possible church trial after coming out as gay
United Methodist pastor faces possible church trial after coming out as gay

United Methodist pastor faces possible church trial after coming out as gay

Pope speaks to Methodists, calls for unity
Pope speaks to Methodists, calls for unity

Pope speaks to Methodists, calls for unity

Bishop and pastor face church trial for same-sex wedding
Bishop and pastor face church trial for same-sex wedding

Bishop and pastor face church trial for same-sex wedding

North Carolina's bathroom law: Hateful bigotry or reasonable precaution?

North Carolina's bathroom law: Hateful bigotry or reasonable precaution?

News
Trump forms Religious Liberty Commission to address 'emerging threats' First Amendment rights
Trump forms Religious Liberty Commission to address 'emerging threats' First Amendment rights

In a new executive action, President Donald Trump has established a new Religious Liberty Commission to bolster protections against “emerging threats” to the US’s longstanding tradition of faith-based freedoms. 

Leviticus: the joyful middle book of the Torah
Leviticus: the joyful middle book of the Torah

Hebrew scholar and Jewish academic Irene Lancaster reflects on Leviticus, holiness and loving your neighbour. 

'The Light He Left Behind': Martin Scorsese unveils new documentary featuring final interview with Pope Francis
'The Light He Left Behind': Martin Scorsese unveils new documentary featuring final interview with Pope Francis

Acclaimed filmmaker Martin Scorsese has announced a forthcoming documentary that will showcase the final on-camera interview with the late Pope Francis, capturing the pontiff’s enduring message of compassion, creativity, and cross-cultural dialogue.

5 things to know about Pope Leo XIV
5 things to know about Pope Leo XIV

Perhaps the most notable aspect of Prevost’s ascension to the papacy is his background.