MP hopes 'common sense' decision in Scottish abortion zone case will lead to change across UK

Rose Docherty
Rose Docherty standing peacefully with her sign.

Carla Lockhart, a DUP Member of Parliament, hopes last week's decision not to prosecute a grandmother for holding a sign within an abortion clinic buffer zone will lead to change across the UK.

She has welcomed the news that the Scottish Procurator Fiscal will not be prosecuting Glaswegian Rose Docherty, 75.

Harassment, intimidation, or influencing decisions about abortion are not permitted within the controversial zones.

Docherty was arrested in February after standing in a buffer zone silently and holding a sign that read “Coercion is a crime, here to talk, only if you want". 

Docherty maintains that her presence in the zone did not contravene any of these restrictions. 

It made international headlines when it was confirmed last week that the Procurator Fiscal in Scotland had decided against pursuing a prosecution against her.

Lockhart, MP for Upper Bann, welcomed the news, saying in the Belfast News Letter, "We have consistently raised concerns that buffer zones by their very nature not only seek to curtail free speech but can criminalise the private thoughts of an individual.

"This of Rose Docherty represents a significant victory for common sense and for the protection of fundamental freedoms.”

Lockhart added that she hoped the Docherty decision would set a precedent, not only in Scotland, but across the wider United Kingdom.

She noted that Docherty’s is not the only such case. Another notable case is Isabel Vaughan-Spruce, who remains under investigation despite being cleared twice previously. 

Docherty's has been one of the most high-profile, though, attracting the attention of the US State Department, which called on Scotland to respect freedom of expression for all.

Lockhart said, "Whilst it is a victory and sets a precedent in Scotland, we should all hope that it may also signal a change across the United Kingdom as a whole."

Vaughan-Spruce, who is co-director of March for Life UK, has faced multiple investigations and arrests for silently praying near an abortion clinic in Kings Norton, Birmingham.

Lockhart continued, "No-one should forget that these laws are not about tackling harassment or abuse.

"They are based on the notion of 'influence' being an offence. As we have witnessed, this can then be used against someone standing peacefully and even silently in the street.”

News
Iran conflict could open doors for the Gospel, says mission agency
Iran conflict could open doors for the Gospel, says mission agency

EEM is also calling for prayers for those impacted by the conflict.

War disrupts Holy Week in Jerusalem
War disrupts Holy Week in Jerusalem

The impact of the escalating conflict in the Middle East region is being felt keenly in Jerusalem.

Thousands gather for installation of Sarah Mullally as 106th Archbishop of Canterbury
Thousands gather for installation of Sarah Mullally as 106th Archbishop of Canterbury

Dame Sarah Mullally is being formally installed today as the 106th Archbishop of Canterbury and the first woman to hold the role in the Church of England’s 1,400-year history.

Church leaders condemn antisemitic ambulance attack
Church leaders condemn antisemitic ambulance attack

Christian leaders have been united in their condemnation of a firebomb attack on four ambulances operated by a Jewish charity.