Nuns tell U.S. Supreme Court: Government shouldn't force religious groups to provide birth control

Sister Loraine Marie Maguire, mother provincial of the Little Sisters of the Poor, speaks to the media after Zubik v. Burwell—an appeal brought by Christian groups demanding full exemption from the requirement to provide insurance covering contraception under the Affordable Care Act—was heard by the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington March 23, 2016. Reuters

The U.S. government has a lot of other venues to provide contraceptives and other forms of birth control to its citizens, so it should not force religious groups to do so.

Lawyers of the nuns from the Little Sisters of the Poor, an order who care for the elderly, presented this main argument last week before the Supreme Court, which appears to be divided in a case that threatens to impose monetary penalties to religious groups that will insist on standing up for their faith and refuse to distribute contraceptives or allow a third party to do so.

At a press conference in front of the Supreme Court building in Washington D.C. on Wednesday, Mark Rienzi, lead attorney for the Little Sisters of the Poor, maintained that the nuns have the support of other religious organisations in their fight for their faith.

"We heard the justices of the Supreme Court comment on the fact that members of many minority religions across the country have stood with the Little Sisters of the Poor, asking the government to do the very simple and right thing here, which is just if the government wants to provide these [contraceptive] services, the government is free to provide them," Rienzi said, as quoted by The Catholic News Agency.

He added that the U.S. government can very well implement its birth control programme even while respecting the rights of religious groups like the Little Sisters of the Poor to practice their faith.

"In every other court case where the government has come before this court and talked about its [health] exchanges, it has told the Court that they are wonderful, they are cheap, they are easy to use, they are affordable, they are great. And all the Little Sisters are asking today is that the government uses all its other programmes to provide the services it wants," the lawyer said.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, however, seemed unconvinced, saying that if all religious exemptions from laws were to be honoured, the government will not be able to implement its programmes.

"Because every believer that's ever come before us, including the people in the military, are saying that 'my soul will be damned in some way'," Sotomayor said, discussing requests for religious exemptions from laws and actions.

"How will we ever have a government that functions?" she added.

Sister Constance Veit, a member of the order, meanwhile said the group is now fearful of the possibility of having to pay a huge fine just for standing up to their faith.

"The fines that we face add up to about $70 million a year across our 27 U.S. homes, so it's pretty frightening," Veit told Fox News.

related articles
Supreme Court to hear nuns\' complaint on Obamacare contraceptive mandate
Supreme Court to hear nuns' complaint on Obamacare contraceptive mandate

Supreme Court to hear nuns' complaint on Obamacare contraceptive mandate

U.S. Supreme Court sets date to hear case on whether Obama administration has right to determine \'what is sin\'
U.S. Supreme Court sets date to hear case on whether Obama administration has right to determine 'what is sin'

U.S. Supreme Court sets date to hear case on whether Obama administration has right to determine 'what is sin'

U.S. nuns ask: Why are big corporations, military exempted from Obamacare contraception mandate but not us?
U.S. nuns ask: Why are big corporations, military exempted from Obamacare contraception mandate but not us?

U.S. nuns ask: Why are big corporations, military exempted from Obamacare contraception mandate but not us?

Supreme Court to hear Christian groups\' challenge to Obamacare over religious freedom and birth control
Supreme Court to hear Christian groups' challenge to Obamacare over religious freedom and birth control

Supreme Court to hear Christian groups' challenge to Obamacare over religious freedom and birth control

Supreme Court faces 4-4 split in Obamacare contraception case
Supreme Court faces 4-4 split in Obamacare contraception case

Supreme Court faces 4-4 split in Obamacare contraception case

News
The story of the pope known as the Apostle to the English
The story of the pope known as the Apostle to the English

Pope Gregory I, known as Gregory the Great, was one of the most important popes, and his positive legacy is still felt today - not least in Britain. This is the story … 

Christians redouble efforts to stop assisted suicide
Christians redouble efforts to stop assisted suicide

Christians are doubling down on efforts to stop assisted suicide becoming legal in England and Wales after Kim Leadbeater's bill was debated in Westminster on Friday. 

Christian leaders unite in Westminster to kick off 2025 ‘Shine Your Light’ evangelism campaign
Christian leaders unite in Westminster to kick off 2025 ‘Shine Your Light’ evangelism campaign

More than 100 Christian leaders recently came together at a parliamentary reception in London for the launch of Shine Your Light 2025 — a bold evangelistic initiative aiming to bring the message of Christ to streets, neighbourhoods, and marketplaces across the UK.

Darlington nurses still waiting for single-sex changing space despite Supreme Court ruling
Darlington nurses still waiting for single-sex changing space despite Supreme Court ruling

An NHS trust has been accused of continually flouting the law around women’s rights by requiring female nurses to get changed in front of a biologically male nurse who goes by the name of “Rose”.