South Dakota's Republican governor vetoes bathroom bill that seeks to protect privacy of students in school

South Dakota Gov. Dennis Daugaard says he is vetoing the bathroom bill since it only ‘invites conflict and litigation, diverting energy and resources from the education of the children of this state.’ (South Dakota Governor's official website)

Republican South Dakota Gov. Dennis Daugaard last week vetoed a bathroom bill that lawmakers said would protect the privacy of students in school.

HB 1088 would require transgenders to only use bathrooms that correspond to their birth sex.

It defies the policy of the Obama administration that transgender students should be allowed to use bathrooms, locker rooms, toilets and showers based on their gender identity, according to Life Site News.

In his veto letter to the state House of Representatives, Daugaard said, "Instead of encouraging local solutions, this bill broadly regulates in a manner that invites conflict and litigation, diverting energy and resources from the education of the children of this state."

"Local school districts can, and have, made necessary restroom and locker room accommodations that serve the best interests of all students, regardless of biological sex or gender identity," the governor said.

He said the bill "removes the ability of local school districts to determine the most appropriate accommodations for their individual students and replaces that flexibility with a state mandate."

Former transgender Walt Heyer, who underwent cosmetic surgery to represent herself as woman but later repented, said, "A man in fear vetoed a bill that would have projected the privacy and dignity of women. The biologically correct women will pay an unnecessary painful price for his failure."

Republican state Rep. Fred Deutsch, who introduced the bill, accused the Obama administration of overstepping in interpreting Title IX's ban on discrimination by extending it to transgenders who need help and counselling.

"It was an honest, sincere effort to protect the bodily privacy of our children," he said, adding that students' birth sex should determine which restroom to use.

"Because I think the national focus on South Dakota should be on our positive business environment, strong labor market and the excellent work our schools do, I am going to ask my legislative colleagues to concur with the Governor's veto. Further focus on this issue will detract from the other significant accomplishments of the legislature this session," Deutsch said.

The Heritage Foundation and the Roman Catholic bishops of South Dakota supported the bill.

LGBT activists praised the governor's veto, saying the bill is an "outrageous legislation attacking transgender kids."

Another South Dakota bill that would allow only boys on boys' sports teams and girls' on girls' teams passed the state House and is pending at the state Senate.

"It's a sad day when a Republican governor in a red state cannot bring himself to sign into law legislation protecting the privacy of girls in female restrooms from 'transgender' males who think they're women," said Peter LaBarbera, president of Americans for Truth about Homosexuality.

related articles
Judge orders company to pay $115,000 to transgender in U.S. sex discrimination case
Judge orders company to pay $115,000 to transgender in U.S. sex discrimination case

Judge orders company to pay $115,000 to transgender in U.S. sex discrimination case

When your pastor asks you to scrub toilets: A lesson on volunteerism
When your pastor asks you to scrub toilets: A lesson on volunteerism

When your pastor asks you to scrub toilets: A lesson on volunteerism

Proposed non-discrimination law being pushed in North Carolina targets Christians, warns Franklin Graham
Proposed non-discrimination law being pushed in North Carolina targets Christians, warns Franklin Graham

Proposed non-discrimination law being pushed in North Carolina targets Christians, warns Franklin Graham

Franklin Graham considers same-sex marriage, transgender issue, abortion as major failures of America
Franklin Graham considers same-sex marriage, transgender issue, abortion as major failures of America

Franklin Graham considers same-sex marriage, transgender issue, abortion as major failures of America

Use of boys\' locker room by a transgender sparks controversy in California school
Use of boys' locker room by a transgender sparks controversy in California school

Use of boys' locker room by a transgender sparks controversy in California school

For first time, Muslim woman leads prayer to Allah at Wisconsin assembly — invited by a Christian lawmaker
For first time, Muslim woman leads prayer to Allah at Wisconsin assembly — invited by a Christian lawmaker

For first time, Muslim woman leads prayer to Allah at Wisconsin assembly — invited by a Christian lawmaker

First in U.S.: South Dakota Senate OKs bill banning transgenders from using restrooms of their gender identity
First in U.S.: South Dakota Senate OKs bill banning transgenders from using restrooms of their gender identity

First in U.S.: South Dakota Senate OKs bill banning transgenders from using restrooms of their gender identity

Man undresses in front of women in Seattle locker room, asserts right to do so under state\'s transgender bathroom policy
Man undresses in front of women in Seattle locker room, asserts right to do so under state's transgender bathroom policy

Man undresses in front of women in Seattle locker room, asserts right to do so under state's transgender bathroom policy

Proposed Florida city legislation granting more protections to LGBT withdrawn
Proposed Florida city legislation granting more protections to LGBT withdrawn

Proposed Florida city legislation granting more protections to LGBT withdrawn

U.S. anti-discrimination laws allowing men to enter women\'s bathrooms denounced
U.S. anti-discrimination laws allowing men to enter women's bathrooms denounced

U.S. anti-discrimination laws allowing men to enter women's bathrooms denounced

Charlotte passes transgender bathroom ordinance, dismissing Christian concerns
Charlotte passes transgender bathroom ordinance, dismissing Christian concerns

Charlotte passes transgender bathroom ordinance, dismissing Christian concerns

U.S. Republican Party urges members to reject LGBT drive for transgenders\' use of opposite-sex bathrooms
U.S. Republican Party urges members to reject LGBT drive for transgenders' use of opposite-sex bathrooms

U.S. Republican Party urges members to reject LGBT drive for transgenders' use of opposite-sex bathrooms

Fighting the \'Hand of God\'? Dangerous End-Time mindset should be resisted, says Dr. Michael Brown
Fighting the 'Hand of God'? Dangerous End-Time mindset should be resisted, says Dr. Michael Brown

Fighting the 'Hand of God'? Dangerous End-Time mindset should be resisted, says Dr. Michael Brown

News
Government told to prioritise biological sex, not gender identity
Government told to prioritise biological sex, not gender identity

Staff in public services were afraid to challenge the new fluid approach to sex and gender, with many feeling that their workplace was a “hostile environment”

Belgian euthanasia stats continue to rise
Belgian euthanasia stats continue to rise

Belgian euthanasia levels reached yet another record high in 2024.

Free Church of Scotland concerned about Scottish Government RE plans
Free Church of Scotland concerned about Scottish Government RE plans

The Free Church of Scotland is concerned that faith will be "marginalised" in schools by the Scottish government

Catholic aid
Catholic aid "the hand of God" in suffering Mozambique

An Islamist insurgency in Cabo Delgado Province has claimed the lives of over 5,000 people, with many more forced to flee from their homes.