U.S., North Carolina battle over transgender rights, firing off lawsuits against each other

Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch (R) and Principal Deputy Assistant Attorney General Vanita Gupta, head of the Civil Rights Division, announce law enforcement action against the state of North Carolina in Washington on May 9, 2016. Reuters

The U.S. federal government and North Carolina are now in direct conflict after the Department of Justice (DOJ) filed a civil rights lawsuit over the state's bathroom privacy law in response to the lawsuits filed by state officials earlier on Monday against the DOJ's directive to stop the implementation of the controversial legislation.

Attorney General Loretta Lynch said the North Carolina legislature and Gov. Pat McCrory have put their state in "direct opposition to federal laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex and gender identity," CNN reports.

"More to the point, they created state-sponsored discrimination against transgender individuals who simply seek to engage in the most private of functions in a place of safety and security, a right taken for granted by most of us," Lynch added.

She said the action being taken by the federal government is "about a great deal more than bathrooms," adding that "this is about the dignity and the respect that we accord our fellow citizens and the laws that we as a people and as a country have enacted to protect them."

In a Monday news conference, McCrory slammed the DOJ's "radical reinterpretation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act" in filing the lawsuit.

The governor also blamed the city of Charlotte for raising the issue of gender identity and public restrooms. The matter was not on the state's agenda, he said, until the city imposed a mandate that "caused major privacy concerns about males entering female facilities and females entering male facilities."

He said the bathroom dispute has now become a national issue that could affect every U.S. company. He called on Congress to revisit the anti-discrimination provisions under Titles VII and IX.

McCrory said the federal government was trying to tell every government agency and company employing more than 15 people "that men should be allowed to use a women's locker room, restroom or shower facility."

The North Carolina lawsuit states that no one is facing discrimination because the law applies equally to everyone.

"All state employees are required to use the bathroom and changing facilities assigned to person of their same biological sex, regardless of gender identity, or transgender status," it says.

McCrory said the Obama administration has not only staked out its position for North Carolina, but for all states, universities and most employers in the U.S. "The right and expectation of privacy in one of the most private areas of our personal lives is now in jeopardy," he warned.

North Carolina could lose millions of dollars in federal education funding by rejecting the DOJ's demand for the state to stop implementing the bathroom law.

People who support HB 2 said the law protects the privacy and safety of individuals.

More than 90 leaders have called on North Carolina to repeal the law including Starbucks, Accenture and Google Ventures, according to the Catholic News Agency (CNA).

Ryan Anderson of The Heritage Foundation said the backlash against the law is "cultural cronyism" where businesses and government collude to have their way.

"In this instance, big business is trying to get the government to impose its cultural values and its definition of sexuality," he said.

He earlier told CNA that anti-discrimination ordinances including sexual orientation and gender identity are being passed "so that anyone who does not comply will be accused of discrimination. It is a way to eliminate dissent."

A poll by Survey USA showed that in North Carolina, 69 percent favoured the repeal of the Charlotte ordinance.

"The American people are in favour of laws that protect their religious freedom and the safety of women and children in restrooms," Anderson said. "It is the elites that are not. Public officials will need courage not to be bullied into submission – whether it is by corporate elites, media elites or Hollywood elite – to enact policies that preserve the common good."

related articles
Obama says North Carolina, Mississippi bathroom laws are \'wrong and should be overturned\'
Obama says North Carolina, Mississippi bathroom laws are 'wrong and should be overturned'

Obama says North Carolina, Mississippi bathroom laws are 'wrong and should be overturned'

U.S. pastor proposes all-gender bathrooms will fully separated stalls, each with its own toilet and amenities
U.S. pastor proposes all-gender bathrooms will fully separated stalls, each with its own toilet and amenities

U.S. pastor proposes all-gender bathrooms will fully separated stalls, each with its own toilet and amenities

Target stands to lose at least 1 million customers due to its new \'inclusive\' bathroom policy
Target stands to lose at least 1 million customers due to its new 'inclusive' bathroom policy

Target stands to lose at least 1 million customers due to its new 'inclusive' bathroom policy

Sex and gender: Is the US government trying to impose a new orthodoxy?
Sex and gender: Is the US government trying to impose a new orthodoxy?

Sex and gender: Is the US government trying to impose a new orthodoxy?

Top U.S. Latino evangelical leader says Donald Trump not a racist, chides Franklin Graham for leaving GOP
Top U.S. Latino evangelical leader says Donald Trump not a racist, chides Franklin Graham for leaving GOP

Top U.S. Latino evangelical leader says Donald Trump not a racist, chides Franklin Graham for leaving GOP

Christian leaders accuse NBA head of hypocrisy, attempt to bully Americans into accepting demands of \'sexual radicals\'
Christian leaders accuse NBA head of hypocrisy, attempt to bully Americans into accepting demands of 'sexual radicals'

Christian leaders accuse NBA head of hypocrisy, attempt to bully Americans into accepting demands of 'sexual radicals'

Why Ted Cruz failed to win over American evangelicals
Why Ted Cruz failed to win over American evangelicals

Why Ted Cruz failed to win over American evangelicals

Why these US Christian colleges want exemption from transgender anti-discrimination rules
Why these US Christian colleges want exemption from transgender anti-discrimination rules

Why these US Christian colleges want exemption from transgender anti-discrimination rules

Obama administration accused of bullying after it warned North Carolina to scrap new restroom law or else lose funding
Obama administration accused of bullying after it warned North Carolina to scrap new restroom law or else lose funding

Obama administration accused of bullying after it warned North Carolina to scrap new restroom law or else lose funding

Families sue U.S. government for pressuring Illinois school to allow transgender in girls\' bathroom
Families sue U.S. government for pressuring Illinois school to allow transgender in girls' bathroom

Families sue U.S. government for pressuring Illinois school to allow transgender in girls' bathroom

2 U.S. Catholic colleges embrace new gender ideology described by Pope Francis as \'demonic\'
2 U.S. Catholic colleges embrace new gender ideology described by Pope Francis as 'demonic'

2 U.S. Catholic colleges embrace new gender ideology described by Pope Francis as 'demonic'

Texas warns Target: \'Allowing men in women\'s restrooms could lead to criminal and otherwise unwanted activity\'
Texas warns Target: 'Allowing men in women's restrooms could lead to criminal and otherwise unwanted activity'

Texas warns Target: 'Allowing men in women's restrooms could lead to criminal and otherwise unwanted activity'

News
Gateway Church founder Robert Morris charged with child sex abuse
Gateway Church founder Robert Morris charged with child sex abuse

Robert Morris, founding pastor of Gateway Church in Southlake, Texas, was indicted on five counts of lewd or indecent acts with a child by a multi-county grand jury in Oklahoma on Wednesday. The indictment stems from allegations made by Cindy Clemishire last June that he sexually abused her over multiple years in the 1980s, beginning when she was 12.

Former Conservative MP has 'no confidence' in assisted dying bill safeguards
Former Conservative MP has 'no confidence' in assisted dying bill safeguards

A Former Conservative MP has "no confidence" in assisted dying bill safeguards

Former bishop gets four years for historic sex offences
Former bishop gets four years for historic sex offences

The former Bishop of Swansea and Brecon has been sentenced to just over four years in prison after admitting sex offences against a young boy.

Why doesn’t the media understand religion?
Why doesn’t the media understand religion?

How can anyone understand our 21st century world without knowing how religious faith impacts global, national and regional events?