U.S. School District Yields To Atheist Group's Demand, Agrees To Remove Ten Commandments Monument

A Ten Commandments monument placed on the campus of Valley High School of New Kensington-Arnold School District in Pennsylvania. (Screenshot/WPXI.com)

A school district in America has yielded to a demand by a group of atheists to remove a Ten Commandments monument in one of the schools under its jurisdiction.

Moreover, the New Kensington-Arnold School District in Pennsylvania will even pay $163,500 in legal fees, including over $40,000 payable to the Wisconsin-based Freedom From Religion Foundation (FFRF) atheist organisation, Christian News reported.

"In order to take the high road, as they say, we compromised and agreed to remove the monument," New Kensington-Arnold School District Superintendent John Pallone said in defence of the school district's decision.

Commenting on this, Fox News & Commentary host Todd Starnes said what the school district did was "hardly a compromise" and "more like appeasement."

In his statement to the press, Pallone said the district decided to surrender to the demand of the FFRF even though it "had a winnable case."

"We're in a position where we just can't continue to fight this distraction," he said.

Pallone even acknowledged that the "opportunist" FFRF lawyers "made a mockery of the judicial system" by forcing "the district into a situation where we had to make this decision," according to Christian News.

Starnes said the school district's response was "infuriating" since it "chose to throw in the towel – for the sake of expedience" even though it "had an opportunity to demonstrate to children how to defend our rights under the Constitution."

"And in doing so – the school district violated an eleventh commandment: Thou Shall Not Tucketh Tail and Run," the conservative commentator said.

The case stemmed from a lawsuit filed in 2012 by self-avowed atheist Marie Schaub.

Schaub claimed the six-foot stone monument erected outside Valley High School in New Kensington, Pennsylvania was a religious symbol and therefore was in violation of the U.S. Constitution. She also complained that the presence of the monument disturbed her and her daughter.

In July 2015, U.S. District Judge Terrence McVerry rejected the claim, saying Schaub "failed to establish that they were forced to come into 'direct, regular, and unwelcome contact' with the Ten Commandments monument..."

However, the FFRF appealed the ruling to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, which overturned McVerry's ruling, saying that Schaub did have a case as removing her daughter from the school to avoid seeing the monument constituted injury.

related articles
Ten Commandments monument in Maryland to stay after complainant drops lawsuit
Ten Commandments monument in Maryland to stay after complainant drops lawsuit

Ten Commandments monument in Maryland to stay after complainant drops lawsuit

U.S. federal court resurrects Ten Commandments monument lawsuit
U.S. federal court resurrects Ten Commandments monument lawsuit

U.S. federal court resurrects Ten Commandments monument lawsuit

Atheists want Ten Commandments painting removed from Kentucky county clerk office
Atheists want Ten Commandments painting removed from Kentucky county clerk office

Atheists want Ten Commandments painting removed from Kentucky county clerk office

Oklahoma Rejects Proposal to Allow Use of Government Property for Religious Purposes
Oklahoma Rejects Proposal to Allow Use of Government Property for Religious Purposes

Oklahoma Rejects Proposal to Allow Use of Government Property for Religious Purposes

Officials in New Mexico Won\'t Remove Ten Commandments Monument Despite Court Order
Officials in New Mexico Won't Remove Ten Commandments Monument Despite Court Order

Officials in New Mexico Won't Remove Ten Commandments Monument Despite Court Order

News
UK Christian charities help raise over £10m for Myanmar earthquake survivors
UK Christian charities help raise over £10m for Myanmar earthquake survivors

A powerful wave of compassion from across the UK has helped raise more than £10m for the people of Myanmar, devastated by a 7.7 magnitude earthquake that hit on 28th March 2025, claiming over 3,000 and leaving many more injured and displaced.

Church of England invests millions in parish renewal and mission expansion
Church of England invests millions in parish renewal and mission expansion

In a major funding boost aimed at revitalising local churches and expanding outreach efforts, the Church of England has announced a new wave of grants supporting parishes across both urban and rural communities. 

Lottery gives £1.69m grant to restore Pugin designs in Nottingham Cathedral
Lottery gives £1.69m grant to restore Pugin designs in Nottingham Cathedral

The grant is part of the cathedral's Restoring Pugin Project

Half of Gaza's Christians hiding in one church
Half of Gaza's Christians hiding in one church

Those who have survived consider themselves lucky