US fertility clinics help parents choose baby's gender in controversial procedure

A human foetus at 10 weeks' old. (Wikimedia Commons)

Fertility clinics in the US are assisting parents to choose their baby's gender under a controversial practice that is legal in some countries.

It is called family balancing or nonmedical sex selection, according to the Wall Street Journal.

"They usually have one, two or three children of one gender," said Daniel Potter, medical director of HRC Fertility, a California based facility which provides the service.

Women who want to select their baby's gender undergo in vitro fertilization (IVF) to make embryos that are tested before being implanted.

The tests, called pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) and IVF can cost $15,000 to $20,000 per cycle and is not covered by insurance plans.

Last June, the American Society for Reproductive Medicine issued its position on the subject, saying that practitioners are under "no ethical obligation to provide or refuse to provide non-medically indicated methods of sex selection."

However, the ethics committee of the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists opposes the practice of sex selection.

"We don't want people to use technology that's really intended to help couples with medical needs for non-medical reasons," said Sigal Klipstein, head of the committee, adding that IVF is very safe with minimal risks.

Potter said half of the patients he attends to for non-medicl sex selection are from overseas.

Director Arthur Caplan of the division of medical ethics at New York University School of Medicine, said non-medical sex selection can become a smokescreen for families who want boys.

"When you are treating the fertile in order to produce something that they prefer as opposed to a disease, I do think you're really opening the door to a potential slope toward eugenics," he said.

Program Director David Kaufman of the National Human Genome Research Institute said he doesn't expect a trend to emerge for designer babies.

Joel Batzofin, medical director of New York Fertility Services in Manhattan, said about 20 percent of patients come for sex selection.

"If people want to avail themselves of the technology, why not?" Batzofin said. "They're not hurting anyone. They're paying for it. [The American Society for Reproductive Medicine] thinks that it's OK."

related articles
Three parent IVF plan called \'dangerous and unethical\' by Christian lobbyists
Three parent IVF plan called 'dangerous and unethical' by Christian lobbyists

Three parent IVF plan called 'dangerous and unethical' by Christian lobbyists

Apple offers to freeze women\'s eggs - a positive step for equality in the workplace?
Apple offers to freeze women's eggs - a positive step for equality in the workplace?

Apple offers to freeze women's eggs - a positive step for equality in the workplace?

Hayley Haynes, woman who was genetically born a man gives birth to healthy twins
Hayley Haynes, woman who was genetically born a man gives birth to healthy twins

Hayley Haynes, woman who was genetically born a man gives birth to healthy twins

World first as three-parent IVF procedure passes crucial Lords vote
World first as three-parent IVF procedure passes crucial Lords vote

World first as three-parent IVF procedure passes crucial Lords vote

Dolce & Gabbana boycotted after deriding gay adoption and IVF babies
Dolce & Gabbana boycotted after deriding gay adoption and IVF babies

Dolce & Gabbana boycotted after deriding gay adoption and IVF babies

News
Dozens of Scottish church leaders warn against legalising assisted suicide
Dozens of Scottish church leaders warn against legalising assisted suicide

Pastors and Christian leaders across Scotland have signed an open letter to MSPs urging them to vote against a draft bill that seeks to legalise assisted suicide. 

Sequel to hit Christian movie 'I Can Only Imagine' gets new release date
Sequel to hit Christian movie 'I Can Only Imagine' gets new release date

The release date for the faith-based film “I Can Only Imagine 2,” the sequel to the 2018 box office hit, is moving from March 20, 2026, to Feb. 20, 2026, Lionsgate and Kingdom Story Company have announced.

First Minister John Swinney among MSPs to vote against Scottish assisted dying bill
First Minister John Swinney among MSPs to vote against Scottish assisted dying bill

Scotland’s First Minister, John Swinney, has confirmed he will vote against the controversial Assisted Dying for Terminally Ill Adults (Scotland) Bill, ahead of its pivotal Stage 1 vote set for Tuesday evening. 

Suicide is a sin - why can't we say so?
Suicide is a sin - why can't we say so?

It might just be me, but amongst all the myriad and somewhat valid objections raised, including by Christians, to "Assisted Dying" (read "Doctors Killing Patients" or "Doctors Helping Patients to Kill Themselves"), I haven't really seen the most important, indeed the all-decisive, one.