Vatican defends appointing Chilean bishop accused of covering up abuse

Bishop Juan Barros attended his first religious service on 21 March but hundreds of Catholics gathered at the Osorno cathedral, south of Santiago to protest the appointment. Reuters

The Vatican on Tuesday strongly defended its appointment of a bishop in Chile despite protests by critics who have accused him of covering up sexual abuse.

Juan Barros was installed on March 21 as new bishop of Osorno as supporters holding white balloons and opponents carrying black ones shouted at each other during the ceremony in the city's cathedral.

The appointment outraged some parishioners, national legislators and abuse victims who said Barros had protected one of the nation's most notorious pedophiles and asked Pope Francis to rescind it.

Deputy spokesman Father Ciro Benedettini, in the Vatican's first official comment on a case that has divided Chileans, said the Vatican's Congregation for Bishops had "carefully examined the prelate's candidature and did not find objective reasons to preclude the appointment".

Several lay members of an international commission the pope set up to advise him on how to root out sexual abuse by clergy also criticized the appointment.

Critics in Chile say Barros was aware of and helped cover up abuse by Father Fernando Karadima, 84, who was a mentor to a number of younger priests, including Barros.

Karadima denied the accusations. Barros denies he had any knowledge that abuse took place.

In 2011, a Vatican investigation found Karadima guilty of abusing teenage boys over many years and ordered him to retire to "a life of prayer and penitence".

A separate criminal case against him collapsed because of the statute of limitations.

SNAP, a U.S.-based victims group, said that by defending Barros' appointment, the pope was "standing by his cruel and hurtful promotion of a bishop who faces credible allegations of enabling, ignoring and watching child sex crimes".

Juan Carlos Cruz, a victim of Karadima now living in the United States said Barros did the pedophile priest's "dirty work". tearing up letters from victims detailing abuse.

"This contradicts everything the pope has said. He was aware of the situation but named (Barros as bishop) anyway," Cruz told Reuters this month. "We were accustomed to getting slapped in the face by the Catholic church (in Chile), but getting slapped by the pope himself is the saddest part."

Some 30 priests and deacons from the Osorno area wrote a letter to the papal nuncio (ambassador) asking that Barros resign.

related articles
Pope Francis meets with Chilean leaders amid sex abuse controversy
Pope Francis meets with Chilean leaders amid sex abuse controversy

Pope Francis meets with Chilean leaders amid sex abuse controversy

Pope Francis escalates case of suspected child abuse by Italian priest
Pope Francis escalates case of suspected child abuse by Italian priest

Pope Francis escalates case of suspected child abuse by Italian priest

News
US religious groups challenge new immigrant enforcement policies
US religious groups challenge new immigrant enforcement policies

A United States Federal Judge has granted an injunction that will prevent immigration agents from carrying out operations in places of worship after a group of religious organisations launched a lawsuit against the Trump administration over new enforcement policies.

Gyles Brandreth joins campaign to end avoidable sight loss
Gyles Brandreth joins campaign to end avoidable sight loss

Gyles Brandreth has thrown his support behind CBM UK’s campaign to end avoidable sight loss.

Church leaders call for 'rethink' of school closures in Ramadan
Church leaders call for 'rethink' of school closures in Ramadan

“We urge the governors of the affected states to reconsider this decision and explore alternative arrangements that respect the rights and freedoms of all citizens.”

Bangor celebrates 1,500 years by honouring cathedral
Bangor celebrates 1,500 years by honouring cathedral

Bangor Cathedral's central role in the city's 1,500 year history will be formally recognised