Vatican plays down expectations over women deacons

Pope Francis has reopened the question of whether women should be ordained as deacons. Reuters

Vatican has played down expectations that Pope Francis might be ready to ordain women as deacons after he had raised hopes among liberal Catholics by promising to set up a commission to study the issue.

Deacons are ordained clerics who sit just behind priests in the Church hierarchy. They can officiate at baptisms, funerals and weddings, but are not allowed to celebrate Mass, hear confessions or anoint the sick.

The role is reserved for men, who, unlike priests, can be married. During a question-and-answer session with nuns on Thursday, the Pope was asked if a commission could be created to study whether women might also serve as deacons.

"It would be good for the church to clarify this point. I agree," the Pope replied, setting off a mammoth debate that spilled out into the media on whether Francis was poised to rock the Church and crack open the all-male clergy.

But 24 hours after Francis's comments, Vatican spokesman Federico Lombardi moved to head off any such speculation.

"One has to be honest. The Pope did not say that he had any intention of introducing ordination for female deacons, much less priestly ordination for women," he told Vatican radio.

"It would be mistaken to reduce the many important things that the Pope said to the nuns to this single question."

The Church teaches that women cannot become priests because Jesus willingly chose only men as his apostles. However, St. Paul refers in the bible to a deaconess called Phoebe, leading liberal Catholics to argue that there is clear precedent for women to play a much more important role in Church life.

Conservative Catholics would certainly put up fierce resistance to any such a move, eager to preserve clear and separate roles for men and women within the Church.

After his election in 2013, Pope Francis swiftly ruled out ordaining women priests. However, he stirred concern among traditionally minded Catholics over what they perceive as his liberal leanings on a range of other issues, from divorce to the use of contraception.

Earlier this year, he overturned centuries of tradition that banned women from a foot-washing service during Lent, upsetting conservatives and delighting women's rights activists.

Church liberals had hailed his call for a commission to look into the question of deacons.

"I can't underscore enough how groundbreaking this is for the Church," said Father James Bretzke, Professor of Moral Theology at the Boston College School of Theology and Ministry.

"It's clear that Pope Francis, I believe, is trying to move toward institutionalising a greater leadership and service role for women in the Church," he added in emailed comments.

The Vatican did not say when the promised commission would be set up or what it would be asked to do.

related articles
Pope Francis tells teens: 'Happiness cannot be downloaded like an app'

Pope Francis tells teens: 'Happiness cannot be downloaded like an app'

Infallibility: Why a key Catholic doctrine is back on the table
Infallibility: Why a key Catholic doctrine is back on the table

Infallibility: Why a key Catholic doctrine is back on the table

Pope Francis to welcome 6,000 homeless pilgrims in Rome
Pope Francis to welcome 6,000 homeless pilgrims in Rome

Pope Francis to welcome 6,000 homeless pilgrims in Rome

Christian and Muslim leaders meet in Rome and pledge \'solidarity\' with the poor and needy
Christian and Muslim leaders meet in Rome and pledge 'solidarity' with the poor and needy

Christian and Muslim leaders meet in Rome and pledge 'solidarity' with the poor and needy

Pope to consider ordaining women deacons
Pope to consider ordaining women deacons

Pope to consider ordaining women deacons

News
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme
Church cautiously welcomes Northern Ireland government programme

The document outlines the governing priorities of Northern Ireland’s government.

Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'
Pope looks to Christ during 'period of trial'

In his weekly Angelus address, Pope Francis gave praise to God as the one who never abandons us, even in times of severe trial.

Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector
Ukraine imprisons Christian conscientious objector

Serhy Semchuk was sentenced to five years and has had all appeals rejected

Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church
Homeless man charged with terrorism after 'fake' attack threat against Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church

A homeless man alleged to have threatened a deadly gas attack on Joel Osteen's Lakewood Church in Houston, Texas, on Christmas Eve has been indicted on a federal terrorism charge.