Washington Supreme Court agrees to hear case of Christian florist who was slapped with anti-discrimination suit

Barronelle Stutzman is challenging the lower court's ruling in the anti-discrimination lawsuit filed against her by a gay couple. (ADF)

The Washington Supreme Court agreed on Wednesday to hear the case of a Christian florist who was found by a court in February last year to have violated the state's anti-discrimination law for refusing to sell flowers to a same-sex couple for their wedding.

Barronelle Stutzman, owner of Arlene's Flowers in Richland, is seeking to reverse the lower court's decision.

The Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) filed a brief with the state Supreme Court last month to challenge the ruling and the state and the American Civil Liberties Union's arguments about the case.

According to the ADF, the lower court ordered Stutzman to pay penalties and attorney's fees for refusing to use her artistic abilities to make flower arrangements for long-time customer Rob Ingersoll and his partner, Curt Freed.

Ingersoll has been Stutzman's client and a friend for nearly 10 years. Ingersoll approached Stutzman on March 1, 2013 to seek her services in arranging flowers for his wedding.

Stutzman instead referred Ingersoll to other florists in the area who could provide such services.

"Barronelle and many others like her around the country have been willing to serve any and all customers, but they are understandably not willing to promote any and all messages," said ADF Senior Counsel Kristen Waggoner. "We hope the Washington Supreme Court will affirm the broad protections that both the U.S. Constitution and the Washington Constitution afford to freedom of speech and conscience."

ADF Senior Counsel Jeremy Tedesco said, "No one should face personal and professional ruin simply for exercising these foundational freedoms. Americans clearly oppose unjust government actions that force people to create expression against their will."

In its brief, the ADF said, "The case boils down to this question: Is there room in our tolerant, diverse, and freedom-loving society for people with different views about the nature of marriage to establish their 'religious (or nonreligious) self-definition in the political, civic and economic life of our larger community...?' The trial court's and [the state's and the ACLU's] answer is 'no.'"

It added, "This is contrary to the best of our historical and constitutional traditions, which mandate that citizens who hold non-majoritarian views be given room to express them and not be coerced, punished and marginalised through force of law."

The ADF said the trial court, the state and ACLU's opinion "that there can never be a free speech exception to public accommodation laws—endangers everyone."

In an op-ed piece in The Seattle Times, Stutzman wrote, "This case is not about refusing service on the basis of sexual orientation or dislike for another person who is preciously created in God's image. I sold flowers to Rob for years. I helped him find someone else to design his wedding arrangements. I count him as a friend."

She added, "I want to believe that a state as diverse as Washington, with our long commitment to personal and religious freedoms, would be as willing to honour my right to make those kinds of choices as it is to honour Rob's right to make his."

related articles
Flower shop owner asks Washington High Court to overturn ruling on same-sex couple discrimination case
Flower shop owner asks Washington High Court to overturn ruling on same-sex couple discrimination case

Flower shop owner asks Washington High Court to overturn ruling on same-sex couple discrimination case

The Great Schism: Why it\'s taken 1,000 years for the Pope and the Patriarch to meet
The Great Schism: Why it's taken 1,000 years for the Pope and the Patriarch to meet

The Great Schism: Why it's taken 1,000 years for the Pope and the Patriarch to meet

Kentucky appeals court asked to uphold ruling favouring Christian t-shirt printer in row with gay group
Kentucky appeals court asked to uphold ruling favouring Christian t-shirt printer in row with gay group

Kentucky appeals court asked to uphold ruling favouring Christian t-shirt printer in row with gay group

Escaped Boko Haram rape victims persecuted and ostracised by own communities
Escaped Boko Haram rape victims persecuted and ostracised by own communities

Escaped Boko Haram rape victims persecuted and ostracised by own communities

LGBT strategy revealed: How they try to compel lawmakers to support transgender bathroom bill
LGBT strategy revealed: How they try to compel lawmakers to support transgender bathroom bill

LGBT strategy revealed: How they try to compel lawmakers to support transgender bathroom bill

Church leaders in India condemn decision to deny equality to low-caste Christians and Muslims
Church leaders in India condemn decision to deny equality to low-caste Christians and Muslims

Church leaders in India condemn decision to deny equality to low-caste Christians and Muslims

First black Southern Baptist president says US race relations worse under Obama
First black Southern Baptist president says US race relations worse under Obama

First black Southern Baptist president says US race relations worse under Obama

Proposed Florida city legislation granting more protections to LGBT withdrawn
Proposed Florida city legislation granting more protections to LGBT withdrawn

Proposed Florida city legislation granting more protections to LGBT withdrawn

Charlotte passes transgender bathroom ordinance, dismissing Christian concerns
Charlotte passes transgender bathroom ordinance, dismissing Christian concerns

Charlotte passes transgender bathroom ordinance, dismissing Christian concerns

Christian couple fined for declining gay marriage ceremony in their New York farm decide not to appeal court decision
Christian couple fined for declining gay marriage ceremony in their New York farm decide not to appeal court decision

Christian couple fined for declining gay marriage ceremony in their New York farm decide not to appeal court decision

Atheists file lawsuit against Texas governor for removal of Bill of Rights \'nativity\' scene at State Capitol
Atheists file lawsuit against Texas governor for removal of Bill of Rights 'nativity' scene at State Capitol

Atheists file lawsuit against Texas governor for removal of Bill of Rights 'nativity' scene at State Capitol

Christian bakers in Texas won\'t make wedding cake for gay couple since they \'run a business that honours God\'
Christian bakers in Texas won't make wedding cake for gay couple since they 'run a business that honours God'

Christian bakers in Texas won't make wedding cake for gay couple since they 'run a business that honours God'

Oregon bakery owners press fight for their religious beliefs, take case to appeals court
Oregon bakery owners press fight for their religious beliefs, take case to appeals court

Oregon bakery owners press fight for their religious beliefs, take case to appeals court

No, God isn\'t dead – but American Christians aren\'t being persecuted, either
No, God isn't dead – but American Christians aren't being persecuted, either

No, God isn't dead – but American Christians aren't being persecuted, either

The Christian bakers \'gay cake\' case has cost £100,000 so far
The Christian bakers 'gay cake' case has cost £100,000 so far

The Christian bakers 'gay cake' case has cost £100,000 so far

Worsening persecution in U.S.: Religious leaders see organised group to demonise Christians
Worsening persecution in U.S.: Religious leaders see organised group to demonise Christians

Worsening persecution in U.S.: Religious leaders see organised group to demonise Christians

News
AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?
AI and the visual interpretation of Scripture: A new era of biblical storytelling?

The relationship between faith and storytelling has always been central to Christianity. From the parables of Jesus to grand cinematic adaptations of biblical narratives, each generation has found new ways to bring Scripture to life. 

Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE
Report calls for standardisation and specialism in RE

An independent review into the national curriculum for schools has highlighted the urgent need for standardised religious education (RE) across the country and greater subject specialism to ensure “mastery in the subject”. 

GP body shifts to ‘unwarranted and misleading’ neutral stance on assisted suicide despite declining support
GP body shifts to ‘unwarranted and misleading’ neutral stance on assisted suicide despite declining support

The Royal College of General Practitioners (RCGP) is facing criticism after changing from its longstanding opposition to assisted suicide to a neutral stance, despite a significant reduction in support among its members for legalising the practice.

Faith leaders pray for Trump
Faith leaders pray for Trump

Faith leaders have gathered to pray for President Trump, but not everyone is happy.