YouTube is within its rights to censor conservative content, court rules

 (Photo: Unsplash/Con Karampelas)

The censorship of conservative content on YouTube is not unlawful, a US court has ruled. 

The US Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled on Wednesday that the video-sharing platform is not compelled by the First Amendment to allow all viewpoints to be shared on the site. 

The ruling was in response to a legal challenge brought by PragerU, an American right-wing non-profit, against YouTube and Google. 

The appeals court upheld the verdict of a lower court that had dismissed the organisation's lawsuit. 

Handing down the judgement, Circuit Judge M Margaret McKeown said that free speech was not guaranteed on YouTube because it was not a public forum.

"Despite YouTube's ubiquity and its role as a publicfacing platform, it remains a private forum, not a public forum subject to judicial scrutiny under the First Amendment," she wrote. 

"PragerU runs headfirst into two insurmountable barriers—the First Amendment and Supreme Court precedent.

"Just last year, the Court held that 'merely hosting speech by others is not a traditional, exclusive public function and does not alone transform private entities into state actors subject to First Amendment constraints.'"

In a statement, PragerU CEO Marissa Streit accused the court of being afraid of Google. 

"As we feared, the Ninth Circuit got this one wrong, and the important issue of online censorship did not get a fair shake in court," Streit said.

"Sadly, it appears as if even the Ninth Circuit is afraid of Goliath — Google. We're not done fighting for free speech and we will keep pushing forward."

News
Shavuot - the festival of second chances
Shavuot - the festival of second chances

Hebrew scholar and Jewish academic Irene Lancaster unpacks the Jewish perspective of Shavuot - the festival known to Christians as Pentecost. 

Could a hidden bias toward religion exist among atheists?
Could a hidden bias toward religion exist among atheists?

A new study led by Dr Will Gervais, Reader in Psychology at Brunel University London, suggests that even committed atheists in some of the world’s most secular societies may intuitively favour religion over atheism. 

Just another unsung saint?
Just another unsung saint?

Big-hearted and charismatic, Subhir cut a splendid dash when he turned up for supper on his Harley-Davidson, complete with motor-cycling leathers.

Churches getting ready for major nationwide prayer initiative over Pentecost
Churches getting ready for major nationwide prayer initiative over Pentecost

In the lead-up to Pentecost weekend, 6 to 8 June, churches throughout the UK are preparing for a 36-hour, round-the-clock prayer event, marking a significant part of the broader Shine Your Light 2025 evangelism initiative.