'Criminal Minds' season 12 news: Writer opens up about altercation with Thomas Gibson; Hotch's return unlikely

Thomas Gibson as Aaron "Hotch" Hotchner in "Criminal Minds" CBS

The writer-producer involved in an altercation with Thomas Gibson that led to his suspension in "Criminal Minds" season 12 has opened up about the incident.

Virgil Williams spoke to People about what led to the actor's departure from the show, and it all started with a line that Gibson wanted to change.

"He came to me with a line change that he wanted. Because of this particular episode, the change that he wanted hurt the story," Williams explained.

"I offered him a fix. He didn't accept the fix. He said, 'Fix it so I'm happy' and then walked off," he went on to say, adding that another tense conversation with the former "Criminal Minds" star followed.

Williams then decided to take the issue to the showrunner to resolve it, but Gibson kicked him in the shin as he walked by him. This, as fans know it, led to "Criminal Minds" season 12 being the actor's final run as Aaron Hotchner.

Interestingly, this is not how it happened according to Gibson, who explained that after Williams rejected the line change and he returned to the set, the writer "started coming towards" him.

"As he brushed past me, my foot came up and tapped him on the leg. If I hadn't moved, he would have run into me. We had some choice words, for which I apologized the next day, and that was it. It was over. We shot the scene, I went home—and I never got to go back," the actor went on to say.

Gibson only appeared in the first two episodes of "Criminal Minds" season 12 and was written off by having his character take on a separate mission that will require his focus and time.

Fans have threatened to boycott the show following Gibson's exit, which gave birth to the #NoHotchNoWatch Twitter campaign. Williams, on the other hand, has no plans to work with the actor again but hopes for the best for him.

Meanwhile, Gibson's absence in "Criminal Minds" season 12 is filled in by Paget Brewster, who returns as a series regular for her role as Emily Prentiss. She was originally going to appear in several episodes only.

"Criminal Minds" season 12 will be back with a new episode, "Elliot's Pond," tomorrow, Nov. 16 at 9 p.m. ET on CBS.

News
UK Christian charities help raise over £10m for Myanmar earthquake survivors
UK Christian charities help raise over £10m for Myanmar earthquake survivors

A powerful wave of compassion from across the UK has helped raise more than £10m for the people of Myanmar, devastated by a 7.7 magnitude earthquake that hit on 28th March 2025, claiming over 3,000 and leaving many more injured and displaced.

Church of England invests millions in parish renewal and mission expansion
Church of England invests millions in parish renewal and mission expansion

In a major funding boost aimed at revitalising local churches and expanding outreach efforts, the Church of England has announced a new wave of grants supporting parishes across both urban and rural communities. 

Lottery gives £1.69m grant to restore Pugin designs in Nottingham Cathedral
Lottery gives £1.69m grant to restore Pugin designs in Nottingham Cathedral

The grant is part of the cathedral's Restoring Pugin Project

Half of Gaza's Christians hiding in one church
Half of Gaza's Christians hiding in one church

Those who have survived consider themselves lucky